By Marc Guggenheim (Writer), Yanick Paquette (Pencils), Ray Snyder (Inker), and Rob Schwager (Colorist)
I like to give a new series at least one full arc to prove its worth. I mention that because Young X-Men #5 marks the conclusion of the first arc and, as such, carries a bit more weight than the issues that came before it. So, with that said, how does it fair?
As a conclusion, the book is a fairly satisfying read. It makes good on the prophetic visions seen by Blindfold early on and still manages to have a decent emotional impact. Unfortunately though, the flaws that have plagued the series from the beginning (inconsistent artwork and uneven writing) are still present. While I enjoyed Guggenheim’s twisting tale (and applaud the fact that he delivers on the death promised), I never felt that I had any investment in the characters. Simply put, I didn’t actually care about what was happening as the stakes got higher and that’s never a good sign. Couple that with artwork that is mediocre at best and you have something that is entirely forgettable. (Grade: C)
-Kyle Posluszny
Filed under: Marvel Comics, Reviews Tagged: | Blindfold, Cannonball, Donald Pierce, Dust, Marc Guggenheim, Marvel, Ray Snyder, Reviews, Rob Schwager, Rockslide, Sunspot, X-Men, Yanick Paquette, Young X-Men #5
