
The Story: With Midnight seemingly caught in the blaze that destroyed the old Gotham Windmill, Batman must look to the past to solve the mystery of Midnight. So just who is Batman’s latest foe? The answer to that question may surprise you…
What’s Good: As with the rest of Gotham After Midnight, the highlight of issue twelve is the artwork. Kelley Jones and Michelle Madsen once again make After Midnight a trippy, surreal reading experience in every way. As for the story, the fairly surprising twist doesn’t make up for the fact that the plodding twelve issue plot could have easily been told within eight issues, but at least it caps things off in a fairly interesting manner. Also worth mentioning is that the twist does allow Kelley Jones to show off more of Batman’s crazy computer, which, in my opinion, is a very good thing.
What’s Not So Good: An interesting twist does little to change the fact that Midnight, as a character, isn’t all that interesting or compelling. And since the entire story pretty much hinged on how well Midnight works, it leaves the conclusion of Gotham After Midnight feeling rather weak overall. Another negative about the book is that Batman’s inner monologues tend to feel both forced and somewhat overdramatic. It makes the reading experience worth a roll of the eyes or two.
Conclusion: For both good and bad, Batman: Gotham After Midnight #12 is…well…a lot more of the same. The art rocks and the storytelling is mediocre…just like in the other eleven issues.
Grade: C
-Kyle Posluszny
Grade
Conclusion