
by Grant Morrison (writer), Philip Tan (penciller), Jonathan Glapion (inker)
The Story: This issue is narrated from Scarlet’s point of view, and jumps off (literally, for the Penguin) right where Morrison left us on the cliff’s edge last issue. Batman and Robin have their hands full, trying to manage the Red Hood and Scarlett, but do make away with the Penguin. They stake out the watering hole they know will draw the Red Hood, but things don’t always work out.
What’s Good: If you like creepy, boy, is this issue for you. I really shouldn’t have read it during lunch. Don’t get me wrong, it’s not gratuitously violent. The violence and brutality are a necessary part of the setting, revealed in incrementally escalating doses. The depraved villains, who would have made a 1950’s horror comic writer proud, serve to set into starker and starker contrast the moral choices Dick Grayson has to face, both against all of Gotham and even against his own sidekick who looks more and more like he would have been more comfortable as the sidekick to Elektra or Wolverine.
And when I say there is a moral choice here, Morrison is being clearer and more explicit every issue. Furthermore, he has found a perfect foil for the new Batman in the Red Hood, someone with a Bat-family past. Dick has inherited not only Bruce’s responsibilities and son, but his failures and enemies as well. And this biggest failure is really clear: “I’m taking Batman’s mission to the next level. We’re going to stamp every last crook in Gotham into the dirt where they belong.” This is a really hard argument to refute, especially with some of the psychos Morrison has populating Gotham. Morrison is putting Dick into a corner. The Red Hood’s shared history with Dick makes him difficult to fight not only physically, but emotionally as well. It isn’t easy to face your father’s failures, even though it is necessary and classically Freudian. The ending is as shocking as the beginning and the middle, and as he’s done with every issue so far, Morrison leaves us hanging for another couple of weeks until the next installment of the caped crusader.
Tan’s art, with the help of Glapion and Sinclair, is excellent. Tan is a great successor to Quitely. The mood of omnipresent menace and depravity leak from his pencils. He picks great action shots, arresting the pose shots (without being gratuitous about the poses), evocative expression angles, and shocks us everywhere with Gotham’s savagery.
What’s Not So Good: Hard to find anything to complain about in this series.
Conclusion: Issue after issue, it’s moody Batman brilliance, redefining the way we will look at the Batman mythos for the next decade.
Grade: A
-DS Arsenault
Grade
Conclusion