
By: Grant Morrison (writer), Andy Clarke (penciller), Scott Hanna (inker)
The Story: Batman versus Robin Part Two: Batman explores the cave network beneath the Wayne Manor, surer than ever that Red Robin is right– Bruce Wayne is alive. In the meantime, Robin and Sexton, exploring the graves behind Wayne Manor, are suddenly accosted by four killers. Something more sinister than the obvious is up, because some kind of Wayne relative is being brought into the picture, as is the daughter of Batman’s greatest enemy.
What’s Good: As always, Morrison feeds out his story in morsels, never satisfying your hunger, but never blowing the pacing either. There is a big, old mystery afoot and it looks like everything is at stake again for the new Batman. The subtle levers being used by Talia to move her puzzle pieces around are intriguing, as is the climactic moment at the end when she springs her trap. Morrison’s command of voice, different voices for different characters, is also well done and brings an authenticity to the interactions, even when some of the characters are doing pretty weird stuff– check out the running monologue around Mister Whips-Himself – creepy… And, as one final point on the writing, Damian steals the show. This is really his issue and it’s a lot of fun to watch him figure things out and squirm over mother issues.
On art, I’ve always liked Clarke, although in other reviews (R.E.B.E.L.S.), I’ve noted that I think he’s better suited for moody, character books rather than action-packed titles. Clarke’s art style (especially the stippled shading and fine lines to show texture) does great work on faces and expressions. The sad, frightened priest on the first page doesn’t need the dialogue to show us how he feels. Same with the expression of the one he blesses– dialogue isn’t needed for this guy to creep us out.
What’s Not So Good: Despite Clarke’s skill at textural detail and expressions, the art was static, which is a real flaw in a book like Batman. Take a look at the splash/credit page. The figures are lifelike in their postures, but lack the dynamism that Kirby and his followers added to the medium. Clarke excels at moody, still images, but a shovel-fight (Yeah, I said shovel-fight!) can’t be a series of still images. I love Clarke, but I don’t think that the editors matched the right artist to this story.
Conclusion: If the ads for the return of Bruce Wayne (including the cover caption) doesn’t have you chomping at the bit for this issue, buy it anyway. Good story. Good characters. And the art is fun to look at, even if it doesn’t propel the story onward.
Grade: B-
-DS Arsenault
Grade
Conclusion