
By: Grant Morrison (writer), Frazer Irving (artist), Janelle Seigel (assistant editor), Mike Marts (editor)
The Story: Batman and Robin Must Die, Part 3: The Joker has Robin in his insane clutches, but he must convince the boy wonder to go after Thomas Wayne instead of giving the Joker his comeuppance. Damian isn’t known for his ability to persuade, though. Batman is in the clutches of Thomas Wayne, who is also a raving lunatic. And Gotham is in the clutches of an addiction-withdrawl infection. All in, a crappy day to be in a cape and tights.
What’s Good: Irving’s art blows the doors off the barn. His attention to detail, deft use of color, and style suited to the moodiness of the psychologically-unhinged, make him my premiere choice for drawing Batman and Robin (even over Quitely). The Joker in the first three pages (well, any pages where he appears, really) is hypnotic. I had to drag my eyes from one panel to the next, because they didn’t want to leave where they were. The layouts were intriguing, with unexpected open white spaces on some pages, and panels to set symbolism and mood, some having classical roots, others having more dystopian 24-hour-TV-news roots. The action sequences, especially of Robin, were really, really good (check out Damian with his boot to the Joker’s throat and the part where he leaps at all of Pyg’s piggies). Brilliant art.
Morrison has been putting in pretty flawless performances in the last few months on BM&R and the Return of Bruce Wayne. This issue is no exception. Each character has his own, vivid voice. Morrison’s choice of words and cadences make the Joker sound unhinged, Thomas Wayne sound British and slimy, Pyg insane, Damian arrogant and frustrated, and Alfred….I’m not sure…was it disdainful or fearful? Doesn’t matter. He sounded different from every other character in the book. Morrison gave each one a feel, so that the art was free to characterize in the areas it does so best: expression, body language, setting, etc. Fine writing all around.
What’s Not So Good: A very minor complaint, but in a couple of spots this issue, the ropes that were supposed to be holding Batman and Robin come loose at pretty dramatically convenient moments. So although Morrison did a great job of creating an unhinged Gotham, a couple of his plot devices seemed to have come from the Mark Twain-Edgar Rice Burroughs’ Book of “Wow, that was a lucky coincidence!” I don’t mind that Morrison did it once, but by the second time, I thought that he was taking short cuts. On the flipside, maybe this is the plot signal that Morrison will be putting the Joker and Thomas Wayne in the boy scouts to learn knots again. Watch out for that weird scoutmaster grin…
Conclusion: A visually stunning issue, chock-full on psychological menace from Gotham’s lunatic edge. Pick this up!
Grade: A-
-DS Arsenault
Grade
Conclusion