
By: David Hine (writer), Moritat (artist), Gabriel Bautista (colorist), Paul Dini (co-feature writer), Mike Ploog (co-feature artist)
The Story: The feud between the Ottoman and Bauhaus families ratchets up when the Spirit discovers a connection between Ophelia Ottoman’s murders, her dead husband, and a long-lost treasure. But since this is Central City, that connection isn’t as clear-cut as you might think.
The Review: When DC included the Spirit in its First Wave revival of pulp heroes, it seemed like a good fit, but also kind of sudden. The Spirit had recently been re-introduced under Darwyn Cooke’s pen and enjoyed success on the first leg of his series, but lost steam after Cooke (and his powerhouse retro-penciling) departed. The Spirit was on the brink of losing his place in Central City to the Flash, who was about to be resurrected in the pages of Final Crisis, before he got transferred from his DCU-prime ongoing to another in the First Wave universe.
The Spirit now lives in a world kept perpetually in a kind of post-Prohibition era, and he thrives here more than he did in a land where metahumans walk the land and the Internet reigns supreme. His skills as a detective and punch-up vigilante get better display when he’s forced to get down and dirty to do his work. While the Spirit lacks the Bat Man’s viciousness and Doc Savage’s intellect, he keeps enough tricks up his sleeve to face down any sticky situation. His scheme to give a pair of lovers a chance at freedom while ensuring they pay for their crimes is both inspired and twisted. The final scenes leave you smirking at the Spirit’s triumph, but anticipating the blow-up that’s sure to come somewhere down the line.
This is the kind of thing Hine does a particularly good job at: portraying the Spirit as Central City’s last, best hope, but pulling back to show the enormity of what the Spirit has to face. Even as the A-story is running full-speed, there are signs laced throughout hinting at just how deep crime goes in this world. Even though each story arc may last only a couple issues and is fairly self-contained, a sense of a much bigger, almost omniscient foe looms at certain beats of the issue. Each case acts as a puzzle piece, but one that fits at unpredictable corners of the bigger picture. It’ll be very exciting when the Spirit figures out exactly what he’s really up against.
The Spirit falls back on old plot tropes from pulp fiction (the dead man’s gambit is pretty much the oldest hustle there is), but Hine makes them work, to a certain extent. His narrative, though talky, keeps the pace even and builds suspense with each new piece of revealing information. At the same time, the whole story just feels a little outdated and if you’re fairly astute, the resolution will come at you from a mile away, even though it plays well at the end.
Still, there’s a lot of fun in immersing yourself in this classic world. Hine really sells the dialogue; it’s credible, but hilarious at the same time, especially where he chooses to emphasize the words (“He’s telling us the treasure’s buried with the dog!” “Damn!”). Even though all the characters have a similar Dick Tracey dialect, Hine makes sure they each have a distinctive voice. This coupled with some careful choices in behavior and words gives some layers to the characterization, though it’s never going to be very deep or complex.
There’s not much to say about Paul Dini’s Christmas feature. It’s a sweet story, but relies on a kind of lame premise with clumsy narration. It also has a pretty severe plot hole, and wraps itself up too neatly. Compared to the much stronger main feature, the backup is pretty weak sauce.
Moritat’s art works really well for the pulp medium. He doesn’t offer detailed lines, but he’s great at setting up a panel to emphasize just the right visuals. His jumps in point-of-view keep this dialogue-heavy issue lively, and his character expressions reveal so much about what the character is thinking, it does as much characterization work as Hine’s writing. This issue skips around in time all over the place, and Gabriel Bautista’s smart use of specific color palettes for each time period prevents confusion from getting out of hand. Mike Ploog’s art on the backup is a perfect fit for Dini’s story, but is actually stronger than the story itself. With any luck, he’ll get better ones to work with in the future.
Conclusion: The lead story works as classic detective stuff and the backup is harmless fluff, but at the end of the day, the success of pulp fiction relies on how colorful its world and characters are, despite their lack of dimension. However, Will Eisner’s iconic contribution to comics is the perfect medium for better, riskier storytelling with old plot structures. Let’s hope Hine takes that risk.
Grade: B
Some Musings: – Corwin, I can dig that you gained weight and scruffed up in prison, but how did you lose half a foot in height?
– Also, I’m sorry, but even in black and white, you look nothing like Santa, and more like the scary, crazy, possibly pedophilic homeless man who yells profanities at me even though all I’m trying to do is get a corn dog at Wienerschnitzel.
– I’ve never gone with the school that believes bulldogs are so ugly they’re cute. I believe they’re so ugly, you have to love them because what else are they gonna get in life?
– Minhquan Nguyen
Grade
Conclusion