By: Paul Levitz (writer), Yildiray Cinar & Daniel HDR (pencillers), Wayne Faucher & Bob Wiacek (inkers), Hi-Fi (colorist)

The Story: The Durlan assassination attempts continue, this time targeting their own people and the Legionnaires themselves.  As the team spreads even thinner to face the growing number of threats, they can only hope the newly elected Legion leader is up to the job.

The Review: If you ever become a fiction writer, in any medium, you’ll learn there aren’t many rules in the business, but here are two that are essential to the success of any story: whatever you’re writing, it must constantly be accomplishing one or both of two things—building character, or advancing the story.  This issue of Legion does none of the former and just a smidgeon of the latter.

In a way, it’s an achievement in itself how an entire issue can go by without accomplishing much of anything.  A new Legion leader is elected, but with no fanfare and without that leader (I’ll resist from spoiling even the leader’s gender) even present in the issue.  The Legionnaires fight several battles with more Durlan assassins and yet no new information about their mission or motivation really comes to light.  Well, except for Tellus’ telepathic probing of one of the murderous Durlans, which results in the following: “Even if only one of us lives, the United Planets Council will die.”  Dire as it sounds, it’s pretty much what the Durlans have been attempting to do the past couple issues without much success.

It’s really troubling how the characters show almost no personality in this issue.  Part of the problem is so much of their dialogue is expository, and that exposition only reiterates what’s already happening.  Their voices have so little character that you could pretty much replace any of the Legionnaires with any of the others and the story would hardly be affected at all.  All the dialogue has the same straightforward, urgent tone that lends well to melodramatically stating the obvious (“You are powerful, human—but you are not a true changer!”  “I can do anything you can, Durlan—and better.”)  I hate to use this word, but sometimes the characters simply sound stupid, as if despite the ten-century jump, their brains are as dry as croutons.

Random time jumps also don’t help.  On one page, we leave Earth Man holding his own against a Durlan.  The next two pages have Shadow Lass and Dream Girl team up to defeat another.  When we get back to Earth Man, he’s crouching on the ground next to a knocked out Colossal Boy and UP councilman, but his opponent is nowhere to be seen and there’s no indication how he lost.

Another missing element is the sense that the story is heading toward a grander destination.  There are a lot of plot threads in play—the Titan refugees, the Durlan intrigue, Earth Man’s new leaf, the mysterious Harmonia Li—but none of them seem to come together in a major way.  And even if these myriad storylines will meet at a later point, that doesn’t address the problem of how sluggish the pace of the series chugs along at now.

Considering how disappointing the story reads, the fact that the art remains the strongest effort of the issue is no big deal.  Yildiray Cinar and Daniel HDR offer strong lines, but little in the way of detail.  Most of the issue involves Legionnaires battling, but the fight choreography just comes across as uninspired.  With all these various powers in play, it makes little sense how much of the battles consist of punching.  The lack of detail affects the storytelling too; in the aforementioned scene of Earth Man defeated, it’s unclear if the UP councilman is dead or not—at least, not from the slight trickle of blood from his lips.

Conclusion: Decent art can’t make up for largely mediocre storytelling.  This issue goes almost nowhere, and can be easily skipped without missing a beat.  If the next installments don’t lead the series in a consistent direction, then there’s not much hope that this revived incarnation of the Legion will outlive its predecessors.

Grade: D+

Some Musings: – Poor Levitz.  The choice of the new Legion leader sure throws a wrench into your more overarching story plans, doesn’t it?  That’s what happens when you let readers decide, if the death of Jason Todd as Robin didn’t already teach us that.

– “Never, ever send boys to do a woman’s work.”  Seriously, Dream Girl?  Your response to a person’s death is a self-righteous, women’s lib cliché?

– “If you are so anxious for that device, you will not get it!”  And a nanny-nanny boo-boo, stick your head in doo-doo to you, too, Durlan!

– I could go on forever with samples of ridiculous dialogue, but I’ll spare you.  It’s actually the most fun I got out of reading this issue.

– Really?  It’s the 30th Century and the most advancement you’ve made to broken-arm medical technology is a metallic sling instead of a fabric one?  How is that even better?

– Minhquan Nguyen

 

Grade

Conclusion