By Ed Brubaker (writer), Butch Guice (pencils), Stefano Gaudiano and Butch Guice with Rick Magyer (inks), Bettie Breitweiser with Frank Martin (colors) and VC’s Joe Caramagna (letters)

The Story: The trial of Bucky Barnes finally gets underway, with his friends working desperately to find evidence to clear him, while Sin watches, waits for just the right moment, and releases a bombshell of her own that could spell the end not only for Bucky’s time as Captain America, but for his very freedom.

What’s Good: Here’s something you haven’t caught me going on about in a Cap book for a while: the artwork! Guice is always solid of course (and his pencils lends themselves particularly well to the moody, dialog-heavy scenes that make up the bulk of this issue), but both he and the art team have completely pulled out all the stops for #613, and deliver one hell of a product. Are the court scenes particularly visually memorable? No, but that’s okay–because the two pages spent on Sin’s nightmare, as well as that final splash page (and why on EARTH wasn’t that last page a cover, at least on a variant or something?) is clearly where all the effort went, and where it belonged. The “wow!” factor of seeing panels like that, just explosions of color and action, after so many pages of focus on talking heads is well worth the wait. Go team Guice!

For a story that has Bucky so squarely at its center, he doesn’t get much panel time in this issue. This actually works out for the best, and what time he is given is absolutely made the most of. I love the fact that they’re finally, expressly working to turn Bucky into the kind of hero that Captain America needs to be. When Dick Grayson took up Batman’s cowl, it was a big deal–but changing the attitude and M.O. of the guy behind the mask, while it affects people in the Bat-verse who deal with him on a daily basis, is not a big deal in the grand scheme of things. As long as there is someone taking the part of the Bat and protecting the people of Gotham, things are okay. Not so with Cap. He is more than just a hero, more than just a costume–he’s more, even, than just an idea. He’s an ideal. He represents the very. very best of what we see in ourselves, and acts as a paragon of justice and virtue to be aspired to. That’s why Steve Rogers so embodied the role, and why I was–and still am–so dubious about Bucky taking up the shield. While Bucky’s scene with the security guards hasn’t erased my concerns, it at least acknowledged this issue, and showed very clearly that Bucky is doing his best to live up to the title that Steve Rogers lent him.

What’s Not So Good: A disclaimer: I am a huge, HUGE fan of procedural shows, especially Law & Order. Probably because of this, I found all of the trial scenes and legal discussions quite interesting and entertaining. However, it’s certainly not your usual Cap fare, and your mileage may certainly vary. The dialog is very well written, interesting and important to the plot, but there is a lot of it, and I could see it getting old pretty fast for someone picking up this book looking for the usual Cap action.

Conclusion: One of the best Cap issues I’ve read in some time. I’m a little confused that there’s only one more issue left in the arc–it’s part three of four and we only just started the trial!–but as long as they keep on this course and don’t try to either wrap things up too quickly, or pull a deus ex machina just to get Bucky out of things with his honor still intact, I’ll count this as the best Bucky-Cap arc to date.

Grade: A- if you like the legal strategizing and courtroom stuff, B+ if you don’t.

-SoldierHawk

Grade

Conclusion