
By: Geoff Johns (writer), Doug Mahnke (penciller), Keith Champagne, Christian Alamy, Tom Nguyen, Mark Irwin (inkers), Randy Mayor (colorist)
The Story: It’s a rage-fest! Atrocitus hunts the Butcher, his entity of rage, the one that matches his red lantern and red power ring. The Butcher is hungry, seeking to feed on the rage of the Earth. But in feeding, he’s stepping on the toes of the Spectre, and you probably don’t want to do that.
What’s Good: This comic made me feel uncomfortable. That’s not a bad thing. When a comic can elicit any kind of emotional response in me, I count it a success. What was up? This was a story about crime and punishment. Now, I’m Canadian. We don’t have the death penalty up here and I think that’s a good thing for a bunch of reasons. What Johns did in this story is to create a villain who had irrefutably, and beyond a shadow of a doubt, done something unspeakable to a child. He’d been tried by the US courts and was about to be executed legally for his crimes. The Butcher offers the father of the victim the chance to make him pay, the way a father of a victim would want him to pay. This is where my discomfort comes from. I am a citizen of a state that has laws and courts (so that revenge is not necessary), but I’m also a father. Johns created a moral situation where my only possible response as a reader is to pitch in with the revenge fantasy and indulge in it with the victim’s father. This journey also worked to shine a light on the dark corners of Atrocitus, the Spectre and the Butcher, which was quite cool. The climax of the book, the end showdown between Spectre and Atrocitus was awesome (I’d love to talk about it but don’t want to spoil).
Artwise, Mahnke and company made Atrocitus and his blood-imagery come alive. The aliens, humanoids, and monsters, as always under this crew, look great. Victim’s father possessed by the Butcher…I don’t want to meet in a dark alley. Same with Atrocitus and his spewing vomit of blood, and even to some extent, the Spectre. The bad humans are creepy and ugly (check out wife-beater on page 1 and child murderer on page 4). Visually, a strong offering.
What’s Not So Good: My regular beef with the GL art crew is their humans, but that’s not new. The way they can get around it is to fill the story with plasticky, textured aliens, instead of plasticky humans. Other artistic details seemed a bit over the top, like the bulging veins in the Spectre’s arms. I wasn’t sure what all that was for or how it added to the story. Obviously, since I mention it here, it distracted me, but these are minor flaws in an otherwise strong issue.
Conclusion: This was a rare issue. Stand-alone. Emotionally powerful. Hauntingly clingy to the insides of your head. Johns did a great job and the art team had his back. Buy this issue, whether you read GL or not. All you need to know in advance is that Atrocitus has anger issues! Enjoy.
Grade: A
-DS Arsenault
Grade
Conclusion