By: JT Krul (writer), Nicola Scott (penciller), Doug Hazlewood (inker), Jason Wright (colorist)

The Story: The Titans track down the source of the genetically modified teens to a seemingly normal high school, only to be buried inside with a slew of crazed adolescents.

The Review: The biggest pitfall a writer can fall into when writing teen fiction is fixating on how maladjusted and self-conscious they can be.  It plays out the same almost every time: the adolescent in question mopes until some significant event slaps them out of it, and boom—one step closer to maturity.  And with that, the after school special ends.

JT Krul stands on the edge of that very same pitfall.  Throughout this issue, the old monsters of the teen world, Loneliness and Low Self-Esteem, haunt not only the highschoolers in danger of becoming even freakier than they apparently feel themselves to be, but also our heroes.  Krul plays out these timeless themes well, but that doesn’t help the material feel any less tired nor, at times, nonsensical.

The characterizations of the Titans take major steps back in their emotional maturity.  Raven waxes poetic over her solitude even among friends.  Superboy feels torn between his loyalties to Smallville and Titans Tower.  Wonder Girl views her leadership capabilities diminishing against her relationship with Superboy.  These aren’t completely terrible conflicts to work through; they just seem like issues these characters have long outgrown.

The shining departures from this trend are Ravager and Robin (Damian flavor).  They bounce well off each other (partnering the two most antisocial young heroes in the DCU almost guarantees good times), but they also exhibit one thing the previously mentioned Titans don’t: self-awareness.  They know how they come across to others, even if they don’t really care that much.  Besides, they have actual problems to deal with: how they’ll redeem their grim backgrounds.  The angst Raven, Superboy, and Wonder Girl are experiencing seem self-inflicted by comparison.

It also doesn’t help that Krul builds up the characters of the “villains” using clichés rather than motivations personal to them.   He literally gathers the triumvirate of teenage tropes: the nondescript kid who feels invisible, the girl who thinks she’s not pretty enough, and the jock trying to outplay the other athletes.  It’s just too easy (not to mention a tad insulting) to limit their characters in this way.  Besides that, Krul doesn’t make much effort in giving them more personality, so throughout the issue, they remain more like caricatures of teenagers than a serious attempt to capture any relatable teen spirit.

The dialogue is wildly fraught with melodrama and at times ventures into silly territory.  Here’s one of the female antagonist’s choice lines: “Hey Wonder Girl?  Nice boots.  Can I have them?”  And here’s Wonder Girl’s brilliant rejoinder: “What do you think?”  Well, I think I can’t take much more of this ridiculous banter.  There’s just something unnatural about characters baldly stating what they’re thinking all the time.  Ravager and Robin once again offer the rare exceptions, but mostly it’s all very cringing reading.

At least Nicola Scott makes the issue look good.  Occasionally the movement (especially during battle) seems a little stiff, but mostly the level of detail, especially to character design and facial features is very strong.  Doug Hazlewood takes it easy on the inks, making sure Scott’s lines remain clearly defined, but not heavy, and Jason Wright’s colors keep the whole thing looking lively.

Conclusion: Teen Titans retreads familiar ground with its current focus on soapy teen drama.  Except for a few bright spots, there’s no evidence this title will return to the must-read glory it got after its re-launch under Geoff Johns.

Grade: C+

-MQ Nguyen

Some Musings: – And the award for Best Statement of the Obvious is: “He’s burying the school!”  And here I thought he was just kicking sand at it–thanks for the update, Wonder Girl!

– If you have telekinesis, why would you waste time mentally hurtling wooden boards at your opponent instead of just mentally seizing your opponent and having your way with them?  Clearly, Barney absorbing the knowledge of a science genius has had very little effect.

– Oh, Krul—I hate to break it to you, man, but no self-respecting teenager says “spaz” anymore.  Believe me—I’ve been mocked by countless students (most of them my own) for saying “spaz.”  That, and “solid” as an exclamation of coolness.

 

Grade

Conclusion