
By J. Michael Straczynski (plot), Chris Roberson (script), Allan Goldman (pencils), Eber Ferreira (inks), Marcelo Maiolo (colors) and John J. Hill (letters)
The Story: Superman continues–still–his trek across the U.S. While keeping himself busy assisting with everyday emergencies in a small town, he discovers a factory that is in danger of exploding. When Lois shows up to write a story about how the factory heads have been dumping chemicals into the local ground water, Superman must weigh the cost of the truth against the jobs of thousands of innocent people.
What’s Good: Great news! For the first time in half a year, reading a Superman comic didn’t piss me off! I know, I was shocked too. But it’s true: while not stellar by any means, this issue is at least decent, competent, and refrains from being insulting or completely and utterly trite. Better yet–and I can’t stress this enough, for the first time since the storyline started–it actually delivers on the premise that the entire storyline is built around: Superman is actually in a town, talking to people and helping them solve actual, basic problems.
My favorite part of the whole book–of the entire storyline so far, really–is the scene with Superman putting out the factory fire. The self-narrating he does, explaining his actions, thought process and the powers he uses to save the day, has a wonderful Golden Age flavor to it that had me smiling the whole way through. Most fun I’ve had reading Supes in quite some time.
What’s Not So Good: I get that Superman is questioning his morals and values. And I also get that this might cause him to decide [small spoilers here] that the truth about the factory’s chemical dumping should be kept a secret. I can buy that. But uh, when did Superman suddenly gain the ability to suspend our First Amendment? He doesn’t just get to unilaterally DECIDE that a reporter can’t run a story by saying, “I’m afraid I can’t allow you to print that”! Why on Earth does Lois pay the slightest bit of attention to him?! Freedom of the press dictates that, within reason, she can print any story that she and her editor see fit. I mean what is Supes gonna do, mess up the Planet offices if they run the story? Give me a break. I’d have had a lot more respect for the whole incident if he talked Lois into seeing his side of things, or something along those lines. Just PROCLAIMING that the story can’t be printed and flying off is ridiculous.
Conclusion: In spite of some very…simple…writing and plotting, this is still far better paced, and far better written, than any book under the Grounded story to date. It is by no means great, but it IS competent, and much more fun than Superman has been in recent memory. That’s not saying a whole lot, but at least it’s a small ray of hope for this much-abused storyline.
Grade: C
-Soldierhawk
Grade
Conclusion