By: Nick Spencer & James Peaty (writers), Bernard Chang (artist), Blond (colorist)

The Story: Of all the dastardly foes Supergirl has faced over the years, who knew the Maiden of Might’s biggest enemy would be…a cell phone app.

The Review: Nick Spencer already has some experience with Supergirl from writing her brief, but delightful guest spot in his Jimmy Olsen feature.  His Supergirl is less strident than Sterling Gates’, but she has the same sensibility and competence.  Spencer works with James Peaty on setting up the premise for the next story arc on this issue, after which Spencer will depart and Peaty will take the reins, solo-style.

Not to throw any dirt on Peaty’s writing (he does, after all, co-write the issue), but it’s too bad Spencer is leaving the title so soon.  From the start he’s got a great handle on not only Supergirl’s character, but on how to bring some fresh, high-stakes conflict to her world.  The strategy of teaming up villains to take down the hero isn’t new, but the use of an iPod-like app to streamline the process is very appropriate for a next-gen superhero.  Without ever explicitly saying as much, the whole concept speaks volumes on the dangers of our increasingly socialized world.

The inventor of the “Foursquare for superhero sightings” app is introduced only as Alex, but his smarmy, holier-than-thou, know-it-all attitude immediately establishes him as Supergirl’s Lex Luthor—the Alex ID drives the nail into the metaphorical coffin.  Time will tell if he’ll have the same antagonistic legacy as Luthor, but as written, he’s quite nearly as complex and sinister.  His high-minded monologues have all the same pragmatic extremism (laced with a few prideful blind spots), and his schemes are just as abominable—even on an individual level.  His hand in the death of one character is sick on a lot of levels.

There’s a terrific blend of drama, comedy, and action in this issue.  Spencer-Peaty keep several storylines running continuously parallel, so you’re never at a loss for interest or excitement.  The panel-to-panel scene cuts toward the end have the feel of an intense TV thriller, and you can’t get a better cliffhanger shot than the final panel.  The best part of all this back-and-forth plotting is every character gets a chance to shine, no matter how incidental their role (even the redheaded bimbo shows a well-rounded personality), and the feeling that as big as the stakes are for the conflict at hand, even bigger ones are coming down the pike.  Let’s bet on Peaty making the most of them.

Bernard Chang is just the artist this title needs.  The issue runs the gamut of gripping drama and explosive action, and he can do it all.  His lines are clean and detailed, making the features and expressions of every character pop out at you in a distinctive way.  His sense of POV in each panel is right on the money, adding to the primetime feel of the issue, and he takes care not to neglect giving attention even to the backgrounds (the portraits on the wall of the university dining hall are just great touches).  Blond adds appropriate mood lighting to every scene, and his colors keep the issue looking vibrant and lively—just right for a title featuring a young superhero.

Conclusion: The previous writing-art team on Supergirl will be duly missed, but the new is shaping up to be just as good, if not better.  It remains to be seen if Peaty will deliver on Spencer’s brilliant start, but so far, the future for the Girl of Steel is looking very bright.

Grade: A

– Minhquan Nguyen



Grade

Conclusion