
By: Brian Wood (writer), Ryan Kelly (art), Jared K. Fletcher (letters) & Shelly Bond (editor)
The Story: A bunch of young women who are freshmen at NYU deal with life in the city.
What’s Good: What a breath of fresh air this was! You know how crummy you feel if you eat junk food for 4 days straight and then eat a nice fresh salad? New York Five is that salad.
This comic introduces us to four young women who are freshmen at NYU. They’re sharing an apartment as they begin their spring semester and adapting to life in NYC. These characters have all the issues and hang-ups that are typical for kids that age: boy problems, problems at school, family issues, home-sick, being almost-but-not-quite grown up, etc. But rather than becoming a kinda comic version of Sex in the City, everything is presented in a much more real and down-to-Earth fashion. Wood does a great job of portraying how important some of these problems can seem to a kid that age while also making it clear that none of these issues are life-and-death. It’s all relative and most of us can remember when getting a bad grade in English was the end of the world even if it seems like small potatoes now. I’ve never been shy admitting my love of comics about teenage girls coming of age (too many women in my life, I guess), and if you enjoy comics on the superhero side like Batgirl, Supergirl or Spider-girl or enjoy things like Love and Rockets you’ll love this issue.
I shudder to think how many pencils Ryan Kelly went through to illustrate this issue because it is sick how much detail is in these panels. The outside panels show trees with intricate branches and all the cracks in the sidewalk. The kitchen is full of cereal boxes, dish towels, magnets on the fridge, overflowing trash cans and such. The architecture in the city is FULLY rendered. My god is this art detailed! And….it is black and white which is a huge bonus for me in a comic like this. This is a realistic comic and things like bright RED hair or a GREEN sweater would detract from the story. A few colorists might add to this story (Val Staples), but most would just screw it up. Plus, when you have B&W art, the line work is just more detailed because the artist has to handle all of the contouring and shading themselves. The girls are all cute without being over sexualized and that’s important because we’re supposed to care about them…. not be having fantasies about them. This comic would be worth buying just for the art.
What’s Not So Good: While not remotely required due to the excellent intro page, this is a follow on to a story by Wood and Kelly called New York Four. I haven’t read it and didn’t feel confused, but it would probably add to my enjoyment to hunt that down (and I plan to). The only other slight complaint is how the issue ended. It just didn’t feel like an end because it left some of the girls kinda hanging in their stories… Some of that is to be expected given the level of realism in a comic like this: real-life problems don’t necessarily distill into 22 page chunks.
I also wonder how this comic is going to come out monthly with the level of detail that Kelly puts into his pages. I don’t really mean this as a criticism, but as I was reading I thought, “No way can this keep up with a monthly schedule because the art is too good.”
Conclusion: Another great comic from Vertigo. Nothing new about that. If you are looking for a change of pace from superheroes or if you just have little sisters who you love, I urge you to check this out. The story is interesting slice-of-life stuff that a lot of people can identify with and the art is incredible.
Grade: B
– Dean Stell
Grade
Conclusion