By: Chad Cabrera (writer), Mike Banting (artist), Sam Gungon (cover colorist)

The Story: It’s not easy trying to make it as a gumshoe in the Wild West.  It’s even harder when the guy who tried to murder your wife is your newest case.

The Review: Manga is an interesting bird in the world of comics.  Beyond the obvious differences in artistic choices (goggly eyes, leaner, shaggier men, etc., an unashamed love for cuteness) are the huge differences in storytelling.  Easterners tend to dwell on symbols, dragging out layers of meaning in even the most ordinary objects and behaviors.  They’re not shy about using long swaths of exposition, out-of-context jokes, and ideas with no bearing on reality.  Cultural differences sometimes make character behavior and motivation completely inexplicable.

Then you have Drop Dead Dangerous, a weird hybrid trying to inject Western culture into all this.  But manga is a medium that’s been crafted so long by Asians it sometimes almost resists the transfusion.  That’s the case of Drop Dead Dangerous.

This is a zero issue, so the real meat of the story is yet to come, but the set-up Chad Cabrera offers is certainly not groundbreaking, not is it even particularly compelling.  The characters are of your garden variety: the woman-obsessed serial murderer, the traumatized lady victim, the tragic private detective, the orphan seeking companionship…  No matter which side of the ocean you’re from, these are stock fiction archetypes.  They play against each other predictably, doing little to separate themselves from the cliché.

Even though the manga is ostensibly a Western (the cowboys and Injuns kind, not the policies and social values of the European and North American west kind) there’s really nothing in the writing that fits the genre.  The Jack the Ripper-type villain and his pursuing P.I. are more pulp or noir figures, and there’s no sense of the machismo, solitude, or lawlessness that really drives the drama of the Western.  The style of the narration and characters comes off too sentimental and melodramatic to convince you this is frontier country.

And this Edgar Allen Poe theme on top of it all is just messily executed.  I confess that as an English major, I may harp a little too hard on this aspect, but it takes a lot of thought and finesse to pull off literary allusions.  You can try using subtle details or even tone to reference a literary work (the Shakespearean elements in Grant Morrison’s Batman, for example) or you can go for an all-out homage (Richard III in Paul Cornell’s Knight and Squire).  But Cabrera gives the villain the name of Poe’s most famous poem and makes some clumsy attempts to insert some of its lines into the writing, but that’s about all.  It seems like a very fanciful, almost random choice.

Mike Banting’s art does little to help the story get some kind of coherent identity.  Besides the cowboy hat Detective Jack Smith wears and everything being made of wood, you’d never know this was a Western.  Even the architecture looks suburbanized—there are trees, for crying out loud.  Banting also goes for a sketchy, generic kind of manga look, with the usual chibi panel tossed in, but with none of the emotional intensity that really makes a manga.  It looks more like a rough doujinshi with all its cross-hatching and thin, bare lines than a finished product.

Conclusion: You have a Western in the guise of a manga populated by pulp characters with a sporadic literary bent using Poe.  It’s a genre mash-up that tries too hard to sell all of these things, but never really becomes digestible.

Grade: D+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Honestly, who would ever admit they’re being “facetious?”  In fact, who would ever use “facetious” conversationally?

– For a lady whose own husband saved her from a psychotic killer on the dot of their anniversary, she seems a little ungrateful with life.  You’d think in a Western that has detectives, a therapist wouldn’t be out of the question.

Grade

Conclusion