By: Too many to list—you’re better off reading the review.

The Story: Jor-El does Mission Impossible; Perry White takes a shot with Wildcat; the many lives of Jimmy Olsen; the inconsistent grammar of Bizarro World; Supergirl’s ten-second boyfriend; Lois Lane’s good deed; and Superboy, the Werewolf Slayer!

The Review: Annuals may be a grab bag of mixed features, they’ve got nothing on these “giants” DC likes to put out now and then.  You can’t always take them too seriously, but they’re often a surprisingly good showcase of unknown or rising talent in DC’s ranks.

Jor-El’s adventure into Krypton’s core starts off strong and has some great thrills, but his stream-of-consciousness narration drags the pace down.  Had Bud Tidwell more page-time, all his Krypton continuity might have paid bigger dividends, but mostly they’re distracting.  Still, you can’t go wrong with Cafu on art duties; from Jor-El’s expression of relief on his successful escape to Krypton’s skyline at night, everything’s just beautiful to look at.  And let’s just agree Bit’s inks and Santiago Arcas’ colors should accompany Cafu’s lines at all times.

Most Daily Planet stories revolve around Lois and Jimmy, the paper’s point men.  But Neil Kleid shows that they’re continuing a journalistic spirit begun by their boss.  Perry White’s boyhood tale of a run-in with Wildcat and the Guardian not only pays tribute to DC’s Golden Age stories, but speaks sentimentally to the bonds between fathers and sons.  Dean Haspiel gives a great retro look to the script that’s appropriate and lively, but also respects the emotional scenes.

In a strange twist, Abhay Khosla and Andy MacDonald’s Jimmy Olsen feature ends up the moodiest story in the issue, sort of discussing the philosophical implications of Jimmy’s multitude of wacky adventures.  It’s narrated and drawn well, and even has some good moments of humor, but lacks grounding.  It feels very Twilight Zone—you sense there’s an important point being made, but the execution is so weird you just wonder how it’s intended to affect or say something about the character.

I have nothing to say about the Bizarro story except it makes little sense—which is fitting, I suppose.  Dan McDaid’s cartoony art is perfect for fun Bizarro hijinks (though the yellowish cast over everything gets nauseating after a while), but Steve Horton doesn’t really offer much in the way of a coherent script, much less one with appreciable humor.

Joe Caramagna gets the right voice for Supergirl—curious, a bit self-conflicted, but hopeful—but it can’t be said he gives her appealing characters to bounce off of.  They seem like they’re just thrown in to give her people to talk to and some easy conflicts.  Sure, there are some clueless guys out there, but these dudes take the cake (“‘Karalinda.’  Asian, huh?”  Seriously?  She’s totally white and blonde!).  Trevor McCarthy draws it fantastically though—his lines are kinetic and youthful, though colored a bit too darkly by Andre Szymanowicz.

Paul Tobin and Colleen Coover really know how to write Lois; I’ve never been more sold on her as Superman’s ideal woman than when her response to her husband’s dismayed “Did you say the tickets were next to a gun?” is a hasty “No.  You must have heard me wrong.”  Getting Lana into the act offers a fun Thelma-and-Louise vibe, but their quest ends too soon and too neatly; it would’ve been nice to see Lois think her way out of more sticky situations.  Amilcar Penna’s art sometimes looks a bit stiff, but it’s clean, dynamic, and colored vibrantly by Chris Beckett.

Aubrey Sitterson’s story of Superboy fed up with Smallville’s lack of pizzazz would have worked, had it been written a few years ago.  But with his current devotion to his civilian life, it’s just difficult to buy into the feature’s premise.  His scuffle with a werewolf could have been more entertaining, but the dialogue is so over-the-top and the motivation so pointless that the whole thing’s kind of a groaner.  Eddy Barrows draws the heck out of it though; it’d be great to see him on a more action-centric ongoing, unlike the “Grounded” Superman title he’s on now.

Conclusion: A surprisingly enjoyable romp with the Superman family, featuring generally stronger art than writing, though there are some good stories in here.  Maybe not worth the total six bucks it’s priced at, but certainly deserves the consideration, which is no small feat.

Grade: B+

-Minhquan Nguyen

 

Grade

Conclusion