
By: Fabien Nicieza (writer), Marcus To (artist), Ray McCarthy (inker), Guy Major (colors)
***Caution: there are a few minor spoilers in here, necessary for the review. Read conclusion first and then you can stop if you want.***
Conclusion: Red Robin #20 was a visually strong issue, but a bit jumbled story-wise. I get the feeling that Nicieza had to get from his last excellent story to a reason for Tim to team up with the Teen Titans and that he wasn’t given a lot of time to do it right. Pick it up if you’re a Red Robin collector, but don’t make this you first issue of Red Robin.
The Story: It turns out that Tim’s great plan that came together last issue in Moscow and the Unternet had a flaw. The Calculator makes a counter-move and Tim has to leap into action to protect Tam. But, he’s in over his head, so calls in some help from his old friends and his psycho stepbrother. Fun ensues.
What’s Good: Visually, To, McCarthy and Major effectively splash leaping action, explosive excitement and sincere buddy-buddy reunions into 22 packed pages. I’m a fan of this art team, because they bring the right level of realistic draftsmanship to the table (it’s what I enjoy in comic art), and yet keep the action moving. Red Robin leaping out into the air to save Tam is evocative, as much so as the subtle smirk on Catman’s face. And, I have to add that To’s version of Tim Wayne is wiry and skinny, making him look like the teenager he is, very different, for example, of the build that Dick Grayson or Bruce Wayne would have.
Story-wise, Nicieza has Tim’s voice down pat, and the dialogue always comes across as strong and honest. OK, it got a bit emotional at the reunion with the Titans, but Tim is a teenager, right? I’ll give him that.
What’s Not So Good: My complaints about this issue are in the plot. Although a lot happened in this issue, it felt like it passed quickly. I wondered why I had that feeling and looked back and I think the story itself was a bit rushed and lacked logic. We jump from success in Russia to Tim having an inconclusive and ambivalent fight with a Secret Six mercenary whose ending didn’t make a lot of sense to me. If Cat-Man tips off the Calculator that Tam has access to the Unternet, how does Tim conclude that ten minutes later, her University dorm will be blown up? The revelation that Tam was safe somewhere else sort of dropped the tension as well (making me wonder if the threat had been worth it) and smacked a bit of writer’s convenience. I thought that the fact that no other student was hurt was a lost opportunity to increase the menace of Calculator (who, up to now strikes me as a giant tool, rather than a figure to be feared), and make this more viscerally personal for Tim. Maybe editors were pushing for this team up to happen now, but the transition from one plot problem to another felt jerky, and for that reason, made the story less satisfying.
Grade: C+
-DS Arsenault
Follow DS on Twitter.
Grade
Conclusion