
By: Geoff Johns (writer), Doug Mahnke (pencils), Keith Champagne, Christian Alamy, Tom Nguyen (inkers), Randy Major (colors)
The Story: The New Guardians, Conclusion: Hal goes toe to toe with Krona, the nutcase Oan who has spent most of the history of the universe imprisoned. Hal doesn’t do as well as he hoped.
What’s Good: I loved Lord of the Rings and really loved the Silmarillion for the deep, deep past in it, when the gods walked with angels and the first elves and the first men. Although I don’t feel it in the day to day of the Green Lantern Corps, the Guardians are the oldest beings in the universe, and Krona is the one bad god. Reading Krona’s lucid moments feels viscerally like the times I read the Silmarillion. Quite cool.
And on the art, Mahnke and company created some brilliant visuals, vibrantly colored by Randy Major (for color work, check out the green of the double splash-page at the beginning, Atrocitus’s attack on Krona, and when Krona strikes back (both pages of it)). Despite some uncertainty in what exactly was happening at times, the art team threw in some strong action sequences with dynamic poses, creepy monsters and unhinged villains.
What’s Not So Good: Firstly, by no stretch of the imagination does this issue conclude the story any more than issue #12 of the World of New Krypton finished that story. I felt ripped off by the ending that (a) didn’t resolve anything, and (b) felt contrived and arbitrary. Secondly, Krona has got a real creepiness going on that is really effective…except when he loses his lucidity and looks like he qualifies for Arkham. That totally diminished him for me. I thought he was this incredibly powerful guy with a deep and subtle axe to grind against not only the Guardians, but the universe. For a while, it looked like he had a strong, opposing moral viewpoint to offer the story (like his disagreements with the Guardians over research and what to do with the entities). I was itching to see why and see how cool that was going to be. When I found out he’s just batty, my hopes for a fascinating, layered and motivated villain were dashed. Thirdly, Hal Jordan’s behaviour (for example, his constant rebuffing of offers of help from the JLA) is childish. He’s trotted out this excuse of worrying about his friends getting in the crossfire a few times, but I was never convinced. These are super-heroes. They get into danger all the time. The JLA helped Hal out during Blackest Night. Why is this any different? My impression of his childishness doesn’t get dispelled by Hal leaping into battle saying, “We’re the good guys. We always win.”
Conclusion: This issue to the arc did not conclude the story and it diminished the dramatic stature of several characters in my eyes. I’ll be tuning in to War of the Green Lanterns, but having to put up with occasionally dodgy issues like this is frustrating.
Grade: C+
-DS Arsenault
Follow DS on Twitter.
Grade
Conclusion