By Ed Brubaker (writer), Butch Guice (pencils), Stefano Gaudiano w/ Rick Magyar and Butch Guice (inks), Bettie Breitweiser (colors), VC’s Joe Caramagna (letters)

The Story: “The Trial of Captain America” arc comes to a conclusion as Bucky faces of with Master Man and Sin, and fights to rescue his friends as well as an American icon.

What’s Good: While Bucky-Cap is still not my favorite thing to happen to this series (and yeah, I’m gonna bemoan the loss of Steve Rogers ’til he takes back the Shield), he’s at least coming into his own. The villains still haven’t gotten past the you’re-not-the-original-and-you’re-not-good-enough taunts, but at least he’s confident enough not to be plagued by that doubt from himself on a regular basis. For some characters, that brand of angst works–hell, that brand of angst even works for Bucky–but it does not work for Captain America.

I really like the artwork overall, which shouldn’t be a shock to anyone–Guice and his crew have done a fantastic job on this book, and have for some time now. I will say that I’m not in love with the panel layouts…all of the white space in between the artwork really, really looks ugly, and chops up the art in a way that doesn’t feel necessary. I know most other books have this as well (and I certainly know that not everyone can do J.H. Williams style spreads all the time) but for some reason I just notice it in this book more than any other. The art just feels cramped. I’d love to see Guice with a little more room to spread his wings and let his pencils work.

Also: special props to cover artist Marko Djurdjevic. That is a poster-worthy image, and one that actually fits the story. (The detail on the scale’s chains are especially nice.) Well done!

What’s Not So Good: Is it possible for an arc to be both too long and too short? It’s only been five months, but it feels like the arc has been going on for a very long time–possibly due to the (deliberately) slow courtrooms scenes in the last couple issues. I loved those scenes, don’t get me wrong (Law & Order geek, after all), but it seems really, really odd to have entire issues devoted to the courtroom, then have Bucky run off to confront the Big Bads, and then resolve the entire trial–which was kind of the point of the arc–in seven pages! Seven! The offhanded way the final evidence is given–not to mention the judge’s rather ridiculous sentence–makes it feel almost like an epilogue, which it shouldn’t. That verdict was ostensibly what this entire arc was building towards, and to throw it away on the third-to-last page (and then to have it immediately upstaged by something even more ridiculous, thus denying Bucky–and the reader–any chance at celebration or catharsis after seeing his name dragged through the mud) was not the way it should have been handled.

Speaking of which: I understand, from a legal perspective, why Bucky and his lawyer decided on a bench trial. (Or at least, I understand the explanation that was given.) But from a story perspective? Boo hiss! I think a jury trial would have been far more dramatic, and far more interesting to watch play out. Now that I’ve seen how the story ends, part of me (the cynical part that I try to avoid letting speak in my reviews) wonders if the whole bench-trial thing was decided just to pass off the deus ex machina ending with some shred of believability.

Conclusion: Not a bad issue, although it brings the current story to a sudden and very ungraceful end. As for the next arc…well, all I can say is, I winced at that final “big” moment in the last panel. Sigh.

Grade: C+

-SoldierHawk

Grade

Conclusion