
By: J.T. Krul (writer), Georges Jeanty (penciller), Rob Hunter (inker), Jason Wright (colorist)
The Story: These exploding Calculator robots are really harshing these Turkish clubbers’ buzz.
The Review: In crossovers, besides the stickiness of mixing up different characters (who may or may not be a good fit for each other), you’ve also got the issue of how the different styles of the writers will work together. It’s usually best for them to co-write the story; you get a more cohesive product that way. You also avoid the position of comparing one writer to another, which may be uncomfortable for the one who comes off weaker.
In this second half of a crossover with Red Robin, Krul shows with painful obviousness that his writing has a ways to go, quality-wise. He’s simply not as deft or nuanced a writer as Fabien Nicieza, who wrote the first half of this story in Red Robin #20.
Their different approaches to dialogue say it all. Nicieza’s takes for granted that these characters have history and know each other. When Tim says, “We should—oh, sorry, Cass—you go,” he doesn’t have to explain what he’s sorry for; you get that from the context and what you know of them. Krul feels the need to make everything explicit, resulting in chunky, in-your-face dialogue like: “Because you didn’t know [he was an android]. And killing him would have felt very real. I couldn’t let you do that.”
The major weakness to Krul’s dialogue has always been that it doesn’t let the characters show distinctive personalities. Most of the lines feel like babble: “If the circumstances were different, this looks like it’d be a fun place.” Not only is this remark just silly (if there weren’t exploding robots around, everyplace would be more fun), but it’s lifeless as well—anybody could have said it. It feels like filler, padding the time until something more meaningful happens.
In terms of plot, there’s no telling exactly which ideas came from whom, but it’s a sure thing Krul has always planned for Damien to depart from the team eventually. Whether this issue is the right one to execute that seems more questionable. The way Krul has the team gushing over Tim’s presence seems to be a clear slap in Damien’s face, and his send-off comes across sudden and a little bitter. The timing just doesn’t seem right for this scene and it handles poorly.
And there are a couple plot points in this issue that, regardless of who came up with them, just do not work. Bloodthirsty Cassie, for one—it just seems like another opportunity to show how much more capable and cool a leader Tim is, which, honestly, feels incredibly tired. And the whole Calculator robot who doesn’t know he’s a robot feels out of place; whatever drama that’s supposed to come from the scene just gets lost—a very weird twist from left field.
Jeanty’s art is a clear step down from either Nicola Scott or Marcus To. Although his panel set-ups are fine, the lines are rather messy, made even muddier by Hunter’s overeager inks. The whole effect feels sloppy and uneven, which only drags down the pace and energy of the already sluggish script. Wright’s colors are fine, but go overboard at times, especially in the club scene where the neon pink washes out the lines.
Conclusion: A disappointing end to a promising premise, serving only to remind us that the Teen Titans aren’t what they used to be, story-wise and creatively.
Grade: C-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – “As far as I’m concerned, you’re my Robin. Always will be.” “And you’ll always be my clone boy.” …and then they kissed.
– Why wait until you’re inside the club to blast your way underground—without warning to the clubbers? Wouldn’t it have been more effective to do it outside then surprise you way into Calculator’s hideout? Comics logic!
Grade
Conclusion