By: Marc Guggenheim (writer), Scott Kolins (artist), Mike Atiyeh (colorist)

The Story: Dr. Chaos shows exactly how he got his credentials in all-out crazy-making.

The Review: Every now and then you’ll hear DC getting some flak for not providing a handy recap page the way Marvel does for all its titles.  You can’t really deny the usefulness of such a feature, as it allows new readers to jump onboard even in the middle of a story arc.  DC’s usual response is something along the lines of a recap page taking a page away from the story, and if a writer’s strong enough, a recap’s not necessary.  True enough.

In this case, Guggenheim devotes the issue’s opening to recapping an event two issues before.  There are several major problems with this move, the most obvious being he ripped the scene and dialogue straight from Justice Society of America #46.  Second problem: it was weak when it first appeared, so reading it again just seems painful.  Third: instead of using one page to sum up the event, he has now used three—and with the dropped page count, that’s three too many.

And if you notice these flaws right off, that puts you in a discouraged frame of mind from the very start—truly unfortunate, as the rest of the issue requires a lot of forgiveness.  The pace of this story has become unearthly, stretching the limits of decompression technique.  Thanks to the time captions Guggenheim inserts to mark scene-jumps, you can easily deduce that over three issues, only forty-five minutes have passed.

Of course, as 24 demonstrates, decompression isn’t so bad as long as you fill the time with enough interest to keep the tension high.  But considering most of the story has been Dr. Chaos further reducing an already ruined city to rubble and a rematch between the team and Scythe—a villain they literally just defeated in the last story arc—you can’t really call such stuff interesting.

Guggenheim does offer a few good lines (Wildcat: “Sonofa—”  Dr. Chaos: “Yes.  How’d you know?”) and moments, but for every one of those, there’s a cringe-worthy scene like Mr. Terrific’s dumbing down.  Now, I’m sure it’s not intended this way, but the idea of making Michael illiterate—it’s just slightly racist, or at least an unfortunate coincidental reflection of a pervasive, negative, racial stereotype.  Is that politically correct enough?

Whatever it is, it feels uncomfortable, and the creative payoff isn’t good enough to sell it.  It’s really unclear where Guggenheim plans to go with this, or the series for that matter.  With the return of the JSA All-Stars at the end (thank God—it was getting really awkward watching Jay, a guy old enough to be my grandpa, get beat down), there may be a merging of the titles and finally a step forward to that grand society spoken of at the start of this arc.  By now, however, it’s hard to care about this utopian vision that in theory already seems poised for messiness.

Kolins’ art may be tailor-made for Flash material—he sells the speed very stylishly—but everything else just looks stiff and unattractive.  Maybe it’s because the setting is at night, but Atiyeh’s colors make all the characters seem dark, almost sludgy.  In any case, you can’t say that the art will make up for the disappointing story—at best, it allows the story to just hang in there.

Conclusion: For a lot of reasons, this issue serves to underscore the fundamental weaknesses of the series as a whole, particularly since Guggenheim took it over.  Depending on the quality of this arc’s conclusion and the start of the next, I may just drop the title altogether.

Grade: D+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – You have to love these covers where half the characters don’t even show up in the issue.

– Yet another United States government conspiracy plot.  Color me nonplussed.

Grade

Conclusion