
By: Peter J. Tomasi (writer), Patrick Gleason (artist), Mick Gray (inks)
The Story: the Tree of Blood, Part 2 of 3: Batman and Robin leap to the rescue of the latest angel suicides only to be confronted by the White Knight, who, appropriate to Gotham City, is crazier that the last villain. Things go downhill for our heroes from there.
What’s Good: The White Knight is an interesting addition to Dick Grayson’s rogues gallery. He’s not your normal psycho skulking in the shadows; he seems to be following a logic that makes sense to him (I tend to look at most of Gotham’s other villains (except for R’as al-Ghul) as unstable and unpredictable). He wouldn’t be much good in a dark alley anyway. The first battle with the White Knight is interesting and I like how it gets shut down (although I have more to say on that below). On the writing, I also liked the small in-jokes and nods to Aparo (a classic Bat-artist) and Siglain (a Bat-editor). Artwise, I loved the burst water main that nearly drowned our heroes, and the Tree of Blood and its decorations were beautiful haunting.
What’s Not So Good: This issue, unlike other issue in the series, lacked oomph. The interplay between Dick and Damian lacked sparks. They sniped at each other, but without the resolution, growth and rapprochement that other writers (including Tomasi) have brought to this duo. Since the relationship between Dick and Damian is the core of this series, this issue felt hollow. A number of other pieces seemed to lack conclusiveness or felt discontinuous as well. The Man-Bat’s family is saved from a jump from a ledge and speaks long enough to provide a clue. Then, they disappear. The fight with the White Knight lasts long enough to get Batman and Robin wet (don’t get me wrong – that encounter had great visuals), but no more. Batman and Robin and Alfred talk a lot only to reveal that the feathers are from peregrine falcons. Batman and Robin go bird-watching, but leave when they are radioed another clue. It felt like a lot of jumping, but disconnectedly.
Conclusion: I can’t recommend this issue, even though I think that the White Knight is a promising villain. The story didn’t come into focus. Hopefully, Tomasi will reveal next issue why he wrote this issue this way.
Grade: C
-DS Arsenault
Follow DS on Twitter.
Grade
Conclusion