
By: Paul Cornell (writer), Jimmy Broxton (artist), Guy Major (colors)
The Story: An American Joker in London.
The Review: It’s almost a sure thing no one knew what to expect going into this series, and certainly as it’s gone on, it’s become even more unpredictable. As it turns out, Knight and Squire aren’t simply Batman and Robin with charming accents. For a while, their style and philosophy toward crime-busting has come off so lighthearted, they came fairly close to parody. But this issue proves they are more than up to the job of taking down the big-name villains.
Regardless of which Dynamic Duo you’re talking about, sooner or later, it had to come down to this: a face-off with the Joker. I don’t think many of us anticipated the original to show up (how does an infamous psychotic manage to bop his way across the pond anyhow?), but Cornell uses him to show not only what K&S are made of, but the overall philosophy of the British culture.
A lot of praise has to be given to our heroes for stepping up to the plate despite confronting a foe with far greater malice and danger than they’re used to—in comparison to a resurrected Richard III, anyway. Especially admirable is Beryl’s design of a clever trap for the Joker in spite of her grief over her beau’s murder—it’s one of the best amidst a lot of examples in this issue of what the Brits lack in outright boldness, they make up for with formidable resilience.
Nowhere is that more evident than in Jarvis Poker’s subtle baiting of his former idol even in the death throes of his disease. How fitting he ends up being the character that learns the most by the story’s end. After all, he reflects the side of Britons that admires American independence, only to learn that a nation as big as America can afford it, while the citizens of an island nation must learn to get along—even heroes and villains. The source of their indefatigable civility is the same thing, which allows them to overcome challenges: in Jarvis’ words, “Sacrifice.”
Besides the light moralizing in this issue, Cornell proves he’s just an enormous character writer. He really brings these strictly reserved figures to life, revealing layers of personality under their stiff upper lips. The scene where Cyril tells Beryl he trusts her to know how well she’s holding up seems low-key, but actually a huge moment when you consider how awkward he is under most circumstances.
Honestly though, Cornell does his best work with the bolder characters; his Joker is nothing short of brilliant, from the punny murders (“—the Good Shepherd can only be said to have been roasted alive—”) to his dark humor (“See? You can participate in a senseless killing!”). Even his disgust of magic (which proves to be his undoing) rings very true—remember him shooting Zatanna in the throat over in Detective Comics?
Broxton has been a fine art companion for Cornell’s script, though his work seems more suited to black-and-white drama than superhero fare. Its plainness suits this series well, though there’s little remarkable about it. I have to call attention to a big snafu on letterer Swands’ part: in one panel, the line “…in my condition” is shown coming from Joker, when it’s obviously Poker.
Conclusion: An appropriate finish to a very unusual series. It’s satisfying in a thoughtful way, though you kind of wish it had done more in the action department.
Grade: A-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – By the way, since when does Joker have mind-control masks like Starro?
– Birthday Girl may just be the most hilarious, appropriate, and awesome heroine ever.
Grade
Conclusion