
By: David Hine (writer), Moritat (artist), Gabriel Bautista (colorist)
The Story: You ever get a feeling from dolls that their eyes keep following you around the room? Well, you should be worried—because actually they might kill you.
The Review: With any genre of art, you’ve got a few ways of going about it: stick to conventions for a traditional, if formulaic, work; stretch the boundaries and give a new spin to the genre’s spirit; or bring in elements from other genres for a mash-up category all its own. An ongoing comic has the luxury of using all three routes as it sees fit for the story it wants to tell.
For the first leg of his run on The Spirit, Hine gave pretty standard fare as far as pulp stories go: mobsters and their dicey business, femme fatales, private eye cases. But lately he’s grown more confident in offering more dramatically challenging material, and now he’s even bringing a bit of retro (even uber-retro, since puppeteers and their servant golems are old news for fiction) sci-fi stuff to the table.
By itself though, the robot mannequin concept would seem gimmicky and out of place in a title so obviously rooted in straight-up detective work. But Hine smartly doesn’t give too much focus to the puppets themselves (although the Spirit doll is all kinds of creepy fun), but rather to their creator, mad-scientist assassin, the Professor. What started out as a rival mafia premise is slowly becoming more of a character piece, the kind of thing Hine’s proven himself very good at.
The little layers Hine gives to the Professor this issue elevate the old man from creepazoid to a sympathetic figure. Even though we know nothing of his history, the way Hine writes his behavior and reactions, especially to Ellen Dolan, says a lot about what a life starved of love he’s had—it certainly explains the robot-dame he has as his escort, and why her physical affections towards him in the end result in her beheading.
The Professor’s obsession with Ellen makes her central to this story arc, a good opportunity to play with her character beyond her activism. Since she’s often spared from the actual dirty work her father and lover go through, she tends to be sidelined, even though she’s been a staple of the Spirit’s world since the beginning. Her kindness to the Professor and her last-minute save of both Commissioner Dolan and the Spirit showcases her heart and spirit, proving there’s something in Central City worth protecting.
Hine is very good at getting details and themes across without a lot of fanfare. He pays such careful attention to his characters’ actions and to setting up scenes that you always get what’s going on beneath the surface of the action. That’s why his narration feels mostly distracting this issue; it’s trying a little too hard to be artsy, and that’s never necessary.
Moritat excels at drawing static scenes and creating atmospheric settings, but his weak point is in the action, which tends to look stiff and artificial. I just have to point out how even though the Spirit has an ax in his shoulder, the rough way Moritat draws it makes you feel like it’s not very threatening.
Conclusion: As faithful as it is to the pulp tradition, The Spirit has always been striven for more from the genre, and Hine continues that ambition.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Not that Moritat is doing a bad job—far from it—but Ladrönn’s covers have been such all kinds of awesome, I’d love to see what he could do with interiors.
– “…anyone packing iron and who has a New York accent…” I think that’s a pretty good rule of thumb for spotting unsavory characters.
Grade
Conclusion