
By: Mike Carey (writer), Steve Kurth (pencils), Allen Martinez (inks), Brian Reber (colors), Joe Caramagna (letters), Sebastian Girner (assistant editor) & Daniel Ketchum (editor)
The Story: Intrigue abounds as the action in Age of X turns inward.
What’s Good: As mentioned in the review of X-Men Legacy #246 two weeks ago, the Age of X event seems to be mostly skipping the traditional Act II of a story. That is a very good storytelling choice by Mike Carey and the editorial team behind Age of X because Act II of stories doesn’t have much impact when we are dealing with characters that we already know well. What is left of Act II deals primarily with revelations about the slightly different nature of these X-Men characters and that is plenty interesting because although we do know Magneto (or “The General”) and he has a very similar personality in this Age of X timeline, he has some fundamental differences from the wild type that are interesting to explore.
This issue also leaves the reader with a lot of mysteries unsolved. We are now 2/3 of the way through Age of X and it is now pretty obvious that the big revelations will be coming right at the end of the story because things are clear as mud right now.
The strongest point of the art is the general layouts. There really isn’t a panel in the issue where it is unclear what is going on with the story. Now, there isn’t anything very adventurous about the pages and panel designs, but Kurth is not sacrificing storytelling by trying to feed us flashy images.
What’s Not So Good: It was more than a little disappointing that this issue didn’t flow at all from the aforementioned X-Men Legacy #246. The big ending for that issue showed the alternate versions of two of the X-Men’s heavy hitters seemingly teaming up to help Legacy (a.k.a. Rogue), but there is zero follow up on that story thread here. That’ll probably come in the next issue of X-Men Legacy, but it is disappointing that a crossover like this one with a singular writer cannot have a linear story. It’ll read fine in trade, but it was disappointing here.
Although it is in some ways enjoyable that this story is keeping the mysteries rolling, we get hit in the face with several new mysteries in this issue. They are presented as if the reader should know instantly what they are (such as the contents of a mysterious box that is found) but they went right over my head. Everyone who reads comics has had that feeling: You turn the page to get to the big reveal and you can tell that you should know what the hell is going on, but you just don’t get it. That is one of the worst feelings in comics.
And, the art on this issue really isn’t working for me. I don’t care for the faces and most of the characters lack the energy that I value so much. For example, there is one scene where the General is busting Kitty Pryde out of her shackles where you need the text to inform you of what is going on in the panel. If you looked at the panel with no words, it could just as easily be the General encasing Kitty in the debris that is drawn around her because there is no sense of motion given to Kitty or the debris. Also, the inking of shadows on the characters’ bodies (Legion’s abs, Legacy’s hands on a splash page) and faces (most pages of Legacy) are just too heavy also. Shadows on bodies just aren’t that black. With a more cartoony art style, I think this could work, but Kurth is pretty realistic and that realism makes my brain wonder what kinds of lighting could produce such harsh shadows or whether none of the other surfaces in the panel would cause any scattered light to partially illuminate these shadows. If an artist is going to be realistic, they play with fire because our brains ask these questions.
Conclusion: The mysteries get a little out of control in this issue and the art can’t save the day. But, after three previous issues in Age of X that were quite good, I still have high hopes for the crossover.
Grade: D+
-Dean Stell
Follow Dean on Twitter.
Grade
Conclusion