By: Robert Elrod

The Story: Is George a cancer-stricken schizo who hallucinates little goblins whining about the filth in his house, or does he have a sinus infection?  We’ll see…

The Review: Generally, you expect the majority of stories to be narrative-driven, with a beginning, middle, and end, or at least the motions of starting someplace and ending someplace different.  But every now and then you get these almost performance-art type pieces, which are more focused on evoking feelings than telling a tale.  Their success depends on how effectively they get their emotions across, and how deeply they linger.

Looking at Tickling a Dead Man, it’s obvious Elrod has no real intent to produce a coherent story for you.  The opening “Recycle” has nothing in common with the later episodes (which feature the same setting and a recurring cast, so to speak) except for themes of inadequacy and lucklessness.  Perhaps that’s the whole point; “Recycle” dreamlike sequence of George becoming more horrifically decapitated preludes the grimness to the rest of the volume.

Even though “Under There,” “Maw,” and “The End” sort of follow each other, they don’t really work together to form a plot or to advance George’s character in any way.  As the title implies, there’s a sense of futility to George’s life, and Elrod seems content in putting George in ever worsening, hopeless situations.  It’s almost masochistic, in a way.  As soon as George attempts to take control of his life, for better or worse, events force him back into a limbo of incompetence.

On the other hand, as hapless as George may be, there’s a running implication that he kind of deserves it.  He’s accused of being a filth-lover with an uncontrollable bladder from Molly, his wife, and the little alien creatures living in his house (who find him so pathetic they don’t even bother hiding from him anymore).  He reacts to both with self-centered venom, but soon his cowardice puts him back in his place of constant powerlessness.

These are interesting details, but there’s a lack of consistency that defeats any message Elrod may be trying to communicating, subconsciously or otherwise.  After all, Molly does seem somewhat sympathetic to George (the fact she still lives with and essentially supports him says as much), and even the alien creatures make attempts to save him from his own despair.  George lives on to suffer another day, but you’re not really interested in seeing much more of that.

Elrod may be trying to inject some irony into Dead Man, what with the sarcastic burns from the alien critters and a couple sight/physical gags amidst of George’s possibly deluded torments.  Almost all comedy comes from discomfiting the audience and getting over the discomfort by laughing, but it’s hard to laugh when the humor’s swimming beneath that much darkness.

Considering the tone this series is going for, you might say the art is purposefully grotesque and twisted, physically distorting and emphasizing the most nauseating of George’s physical features to gross effect.  But that doesn’t make the art any easier to look at, and it’s unclear how much of it is due to Elrod’s artistic limitations rather than actual aesthetic choices.

Conclusion: Like much of performance art and modern poetry, you just have to be in the right kind of mood to even begin to embrace Tickling a Dead Man—but how often are you in the mood for pointless, self-inflicted suffering?

Grade: C-

– Minhquan Nguyen

 

Grade

Conclusion