
By: Marc Guggenheim (writer), Scott Kolins (artist), Mike Atiyeh (colorist)
The Story: What’s better than the JSA? Double the JSA.
The Review: As the short-lived Heroes demonstrated, a massive cast can be a great thing for a series to have: the mix of personalities and storylines do a lot to grab and sustain your interest. But cross a certain threshold, and an inflated cast quickly becomes a burden: the difficulty of giving each character enough attention or a sizable role to play easily dilutes the pace and substance of the overall plot, leaving little for you to be invested in.
The return of the JSA All-Stars to the fold will likely do precisely the latter. You can see the warning signs in this issue’s action sequences alone. Rather than creating order to how the teamwork use their various abilities in tandem, Guggenheim tosses them almost randomly in Dr. Chaos’ and Scythe’s paths. With the JSA lacking serious firepower, it feels like the All-Stars had to be brought in to get the job done—it’s not as if they contribute to the story any other way.
With all the action being so aimless, it serves only to distract from the core element of the story arc, which is Guggenheim’s concept of an actual city-society dedicated to justice. It’s a potentially interesting idea that he’s not even begun to describe or execute in any way, but is still trying to convince you it’s this great idea. He has characters like Red Beetle saying things like, “What you guys’re doing here, fixing things…that’s holy work,” as if by having it said, it’ll convince you it’s so.
But then there’s a lot of empty talk to this series. Most of the conversations between the characters are very roundabout, where they’re just hammering the same talking points (Lightning’s comatose state, Green Lantern’s trauma, Mr. Terrific’s degrading intelligence, etc.) to death. It takes up more than half the issue, and none of it shows character or develops relationships. Despite their interaction, they all remain a little flat and one-track-minded.
Perhaps the most irritating character and plot element, all in one, is the late mayor’s assistant, Mr. Hogan. His sudden self-righteous conviction toward the creepy old senator(?) seems rather hypocritical. After all, he hired Dr. Chaos in the first place (which even the supposedly dastardly senator didn’t approve of), and that led to the mayor’s death, Lightning’s coma, Scythe’s release, and all the subsequent risk to the already ruined city. Legally and morally, Mr. Hogan should be disgraced and finished—but then who would nominate the Flash to be the new mayor?
There’s a chance all the script’s weaknesses might have been better hidden if the art had done a tremendous job selling them—but it does not. Kolins’ work has been largely stiff, lacking in energy, over-inked, and awkwardly paneled, all of which is exacerbated by Atiyeh’s muddy colors. A good example of Kolins’ artistic limitations: his redesign of Alan Scott’s costume, which is basically a giant lantern around his waist, the handle popping up behind his head like a halo—it’d be right at home with the cheesiest chorus girl outfit from a fifties musical.
Conclusion: It just becomes increasingly difficult to find things to like about this series. Word of warning: if there’s no drastic improvement by the 50th issue, I’m done—as I suspect many of us already are.
Grade: D
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Love how in the panel where it says “a few speedsters on hand to help with rebuilding infrastructure” it just shows Jesse Quick and Jay running around in a circle.
– “You’d think I came outta the closet again or something…” Alright, alright, we get it—you’re gay, and that’s a big deal because you’re in a comic book, congratulations—can we move on, please?
Grade
Conclusion