By: James Peaty (writer), Bernard Chang (artist), Blond (colorist)

The Story: Honestly, Supergirl’s had it up to here with clones.

The Review: In a Newsarama interview, Nick Spencer described his departure from DC and subsequently Supergirl as differences in conceived direction for the character.  He didn’t go into much detail as to what those differences entailed, but you can figure it out by comparing how this story arc started and how it’s turning out now.

This arc introduced the Flyover app, which was meant as a tool for the public to track their most beloved superheroes, and in doing so unintentionally assure the heroes’ destruction.  The idea is classic Spencer: smart, true-to-life, yet still a blind to something even more insidious.  But two issues in, the app idea lost focus; while Alex claimed to target all teen heroes, it seems the Flyover plot has been completely abandoned.

Instead you get more standard telepathic clone hijinks, which certainly don’t have the twisted subtlety of the Flyover app.  Still, it’d be entertaining enough if Peaty had tried to tie it into Spencer’s initial ideas a little more craftily, but he doesn’t.  The fact that such a central concept could be dropped midway through the arc indicates just how forcefully Peaty is attempting to switch gears on this story.

He does it none too gracefully either.  Catherine Devereux is a character whose part should’ve been done after Alex kills off her cancer-stricken son in the arc’s first issue.  Instead she returns to give Lois a midnight-hour confession of new facts on top of the confession she already gave before: Alex is actually a Cadmus experiment she developed a bond with and ultimately freed—which makes you wonder why he so cruelly hurt her in the first place.

It’s hard to qualify weak dialogue, but Peaty delivers a lot of well-worn clichés (it doesn’t get more so than “No…NOOOOO!!”), melodramatic repetition (“How unfeeling.  How inhumane.”), and punny, obviously “written” lines (“But you just had to go and be ‘super,’ didn’t you?”).  If you compare this stuff to what you got in Supergirl #60, there’s no clearer evidence of how integral Spencer’s writing was to the early enjoyment of this arc.

But even more painful than the character interaction is the execution of the plot itself, which has clearly derailed into an “anything goes” situation.  Spoiler alert—Alex turns out to be Dubbilex, a staple Cadmus character—only he got killed in a Jimmy Olsen special a couple years ago.  Let’s say this Dubbilex is a clone, or whatever.  It’s still a weird use of a character that’s always been a heroic ally, particularly Superboy’s early days—just check out the Young Justice pilot.

Chang’s art can only do so much to save this title from complete banality.  You have to love the execution of his paneling, which does its best to bring more energy to a script that really relies on gasp-illiciting character revelations for its tension.  Again, just check out the meticulously plotted scene-cutting from #60 to see the difference in how much more driven this story felt compared to now.  A shoutout to Blond for lending dramatic colors to otherwise lifeless scenes.

Conclusion: If this is the direction DC wants for Supergirl, then I’m afraid I’ll have to place my support behind Spencer’s.  Whatever it was, it had to be better than what we’re getting now—too bad we won’t ever get to see it.

Grade: C

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – “He’s got my friends!”  Since when was so chummy with Blue Beetle, Miss Martian, and Damian Wayne (who I thought you couldn’t stand) she considered them friends?

– What a total jag—he basically let Supergirl run headfirst into an unbreakable forcefield because “It’s much better if she finds out for herself.”  Would a word of warning have been so hard?

Grade

Conclusion