By: Kieron Gillen (writer), Terry Dodson (pencils), Rachel Dodson (inks), Justin Ponsor (colors), Joe Caramagna (letters), Jordan D. White (assistant editor), Daniel Ketchum (associate editor) & Nick Lowe (editor)

The Story: Would you let the aliens from Breakworld sleep on the couch?

What’s Good: If you liked Joss Whedon’s Astonishing X-Men run from a few years ago, you should really enjoy this issue because Gillen is playing with most of Whedon’s stories from those issues.  Isn’t it funny that a series that was only marginally “in continuity” back when it was published has ended up being so influential today?  Just goes to show that there is a difference between “continuity” and “things happening simultaneously” and those things like really late issues don’t matter so much years down the road.  Time surely grants perspective.

Anyway, Gillen clearly has a good handle on all the characters at play here: Agent Brand is prickly, Emma is haughty, Cyclops feels responsible, Colossus is dutiful and loyal, Magneto is driven, etc.  As fans, we could rattle off the personality attributes of the core X-Men, but I think it is a lot harder to write dialog and pencil and ink the pages such that those characters we know and love come shining through.

The action in this issue is all good and I’m sure it won’t come as any surprise that the Breakworld aliens are not quite as benign as they make out and I’ll be very curious to see how [SPOILERS] them attacking Magneto with “the cure” will work out.  My recollection is that he isn’t really a mutant any more and that the High Evolutionary did something to him that approximated his mutant powers.  We’ll see, but Magneto clearly has a role to play in this story (along with the “space tin”) and it’ll be fun to see what happens.

The Dodson’s again do a great job with the art.  I really love artists who have a distinct style where you can open the comic and say, “This is drawn by Terry and Rachel Dodson.”  One thing that I find really impressive about their work is how much acting and emoting their characters do given their grounding in realism.  And, their faithfulness to human anatomy (beyond the huge boobs) is pretty uncanny.  I never get distracted by the length of a finger or a muscle that seems to be in the wrong place.  Very nice…

Finally: HUGE bonus points for a story-arc that isn’t Wolverine centric.  Love that this arc is revolving heavily around Colossus.  Let the furry Cannuck save the day in the Avengers.

What’s Not So Good: We’re not done with the story yet, so we’ve yet to see what Cyclops does next, but I do find it a little hard to fathom that Cyclops wouldn’t have seen the possibility of the aliens attacking and not have 5 contingency plans in place.  It’s very possible that this will come in the next issue, but Cyclops is usually so good and out-thinking the bad guys that you’d think he’d have someone like Danger lurking in the shadows at all times to put down an attack the second it starts and not after Madison has gotten his head smashed & Magneto has gotten attacked.

But, like I said, I’m willing to wait for the end of the story and can accept some of this stuff as drama.

Conclusion: Gillen really has a good handle on the X-Men characters and that means that this franchise is in good hands.  Based on early returns, he should have a pretty good run on the title.

Grade: B

-Dean Stell

Follow Dean on Twitter.

Follow WCBR on Twitter and Facebook.

Grade

Conclusion