
By: Jeff Lemire (writer), Marco Rudy with Daniel HDR (artists), Jamie Grant & Dom Regan (colorists)
The Story: Superboy discovers what the fuss is all about with these hallucinogenic plants.
The Review: Ever since Geoff Johns wrote Superboy as the product of the world’s greatest hero and the world’s greatest villain, this dual nature has become a focal point of his character—too much so, in fact. Ignoring the fact that genetics don’t really work that way, this plot point has infected almost every Superboy story since it first came to light, which has really cramped the Kid of Steel’s style. It’s like writers are trying to wring the issue for all the angst it’s worth.
Superboy’s nightmare come to life falls under those lines. Now, there’s nothing wrong with the way Lemire executes the story. He actually keeps things clipping at a quick pace with his habit of jarring scene-cuts. You’re constantly shunted back and forth between Superboy and Psionic Lad’s present mystery in orbital space, and the future apocalyptic hellscape, which Connor apparently unleashes on the world. It definitely keeps you invested in what the heck is going on.
Instinct tells you to think this is where Psi-Lad reveals his true colors. You know he’s from the future, and that it’s a grim dystopia (or so he says), and he’s intended to turn on Superboy at some point, so all the signs for his betrayal get put in place. But once Lori and Red Robin show up in this alternate timeline, and they don’t seem to get from Connor’s t-shirt/jeans get-up that he’s not the ruthless murderer they seem to know, you know something fishy’s happening.
Even when the Mercy plant shows up, you can’t be sure you know where the plot is going. It’s such a common plot device in the DCU that once you see it, you can almost write the rest of the issue yourself. But Lemire gives it a fresh spin by making it work exactly opposite to how it usually functions, and with Psi-Lad’s potential for treachery always a constant in the back of your mind, you don’t know if the psycho-flora isn’t just part of the kid’s dastardly plan.
Then comes Superboy’s encounter with Lex Luthor and the ghost of Ma Kent, and all that careful plot twisting fades in favor of all the emotional outpouring—and all the melodrama—you’d expect from such a scene. Again, Lemire writes it well, but this internal conflict has been done so often, you can easily figure how it’ll turn out, even with Psi-Lad’s interference.
There’s quite a mess of artists working on this issue, and it shows—badly. It’d look more manageable if Rudy did one sequence and HDR the other, but they seem to switch off even from panel to panel, giving you strong, minimal lines (mimicking Pier Gallo’s puppy-fat faces) one moment and sketchy, artsy stuff the next. The colors similarly switch back and forth between Grant’s obviously sickly effects and a monochromatic, almost watercolor look that makes the already distorted lines even harder to see. Frankly, I’m eager to see interiors done by Karl Kerschl, who draws a convincing, youthful, kinetic, and ominous (love the red pupils) Superboy on the cover. That is the style a title like this needs, to add energy to Lemire’s low-key script.
Conclusion: If Superboy’s hero-villain persona hadn’t been exploited so many times before, this would have been a much more powerful story, though still solidly told. Unfortunately, art by committee shows one of its worst examples here, making the title’s look still its weakest point.
Grade: C
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – I have to agree with Simon—Red Robin, Elongated Lass, a Hawkman lookalike, and a Negative Man kind of figure aren’t exactly the dream team to take down Superboy.
Grade
Conclusion