
By: Daniel Way (writer), Jason Pearson & Sara Pichelli (pencils), Karl Story & Pichelli (inks), Sonia Oback (colors), Joe Caramagna (letters), Daniel Ketchum (associate editor) & Nick Lowe (editor)
The Story: The Astonishing X-Men battle Fin Fang Foom in Tokyo.
What’s Good: Well, the basic part of the story: The X-Men battling Fin Fang Foom in Toyko with all the glittery neon signs is pretty cool. There’s all the fun tropes of giant monster battles: stuff getting smashed, heroes hiding behind cars from the giant monster, Wolverine jumping on FFF’s back and looking about as big as an ant…. It isn’t real deep, but it’s still kinda fun and there’s promise of more monster battles next month (or whenever this title deigns to drop another issue on us) due to the reveal that the main villain is Mentallo and he has seized Monster Island and is controlling the monsters (including FFF).
It was also nice to see Armor get a little bit of time on the page. Count me as a big fan of the Whedon Astonishing X-Men where he did a lot to establish Armor as a three-dimensional character. It never made sense to me why Marvel would have a “name” writer develop a young character, make her viable and then just have her sit on the shelf for 3-4 years, so it’s nice to see her back in action (and with augmented powers to boot).
What’s Not So Good: There are a bunch of things working against this title. For one thing, I really didn’t remember the bigger plot with Roxxon and Mentallo because issue #35 came out months ago (February, I think). And this is really disappointing because the Daniel Way – Jason Pearson relaunch of this title was after the Ellis – Jimenez team took 9 months to get out the final two issues of the Exogenetic arc. When Marvel announced Way/Pearson, it was with the air of, “Now it will be on time!” Well, we have a problem because the “new direction” is suffering delays too. And, that just begs the question of whether this title is even necessary. We already have a LOT of ongoing X-titles, do we need another one that cannot ship on time?
And, the art is kinda a mess. For one thing, Jason Pearson and Sara Pichelli really aren’t the same type of artist and the transition from one to the other is pretty stark. I’m going to go out on a limb and guess that Pearson got behind and Pichelli had to quickly save the day and, of the two, I greatly preferred Pichelli’s work (although her Wolverine could use a little work) and think she’d be a nice addition for the series. So, the upshot on the art is that there is some good, but there’s some bad too (i.e. Pearson’s Armor looks ~10 years old).
Conclusion: This poor title just can’t get out of it’s own way and seems cursed when it comes to release dates: 37 issues in SEVEN years. If this title had shipped monthly, we’d be on issue 80 something. For comparison’s sake, Uncanny X-Men was on issue 444 the month that Astonishing launched (and it’s up to 536 now). It just kills a title when you open it and can’t remember the ongoing story because it has only released a couple of issues this year. If the X-editors could get Pichelli so stick around for art duties, this title has some promise, but otherwise, we probably have enough X-titles on the shelves right now.
Grade: D+ (docking a few points for turning in its homework late).
– Dean Stell
Follow Dean on Twitter.
Grade
Conclusion