By: Paul Levitz (writer), Yildiray Cinar & Jonathan Glapion (artists), Hi-Fi (colorist)

The Story: Geez, Saturn Queen–someone took her total jag pill this morning.

The Review: One of the major weaknesses of this story arc so far—and frankly, there have been many—is how much we still don’t know about this mysterious benefactor-guide of Saturn Queen’s, especially since he/she/it has got her planet-hopping all over the place trying to find these three ancient worlds for some reason or other.  The lack of a clear goal for our villains definitely makes the stakes for the Legionnaires all that less interesting.

This issue we actually get some face-time with the “blue flame” entity, a little blue dude in a kind of alien kilt-skirt, just about the cutest fella to ever dream of senseless galactic chaos.  Considering the fairly enormous scale of Saturn Queen’s mission, you’d think the reveal of her mission-giver would have a similarly enormous impact, but he doesn’t.  You get a face to this enemy, but that’s about it.

Despite all his grandstanding (“…my dreams over the endless centuries of exile shall be fulfilled…”), you really learn nothing about his goals.  Several issues into the story arc, we still don’t know what the big plan is here, other than a vague desire to destroy “galactic civilization” (the United Planets, I’m assuming).  Considering how many times the Legion has defeated that ambition from villains with far more threatening appearances, we’ve no reason to believe this time will be any different.

One new wrinkle involves Saturn Queen’s offer to have Earth Man join her team in exchange for having his way with Earth when she and Blue Flame Dude destroy all order, or whatever.  If this testing of our favorite xenophobe sheds light on how he switched loyalties to the Legion in the first place, or at least how he and Shadow Lass hooked up, then it’ll be worthwhile.  But since almost every Legionnaire expects him to backstab them at some point anyway, his possible betrayal doesn’t have all that much tension.

And each time you think you’re on the verge of finally learning something about Harmonia Li, you get instead more highbrow vagaries (“There are consequences more important than his life, or yours…”) and a scene-cut.  It’s really reached the point where you can’t bring yourself to care anymore; whatever her significance to this title, it can’t possible merit thirteen issues of guest appearances, only to dance around the subject at hand.

The final panel features a lifelessly written line (“…but first, we must stop draining his energies…”) and a melodramatic reply (“No!”), a fitting sign-off to an issue, and series overall, that’s been both bland yet over-fraught with pointless tension.

Cinar and Glapion offer art that essentially does the bare minimum to make the script function.  But looking at how stiff the action looks, and how all the faces have the same expression of uber-grimness, it all ends up feeling as bland and repetitive as the writing.  DC art at its weakest tends not to be ugly or anything; it’s just incredibly unremarkable and uninspired.

Conclusion: I’m officially reaching the threshold where this comic provides too little meat for the value.  Unless some drastic improvements pop up, this title gets the drop from my pull list.

Grade: D+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Come to think of it, that blue guy bears an eerie resemblance to Aang from Avatar, doesn’t he?  Especially when he went into the Avatar State with the fish god of the ocean in the first season finale.

Grade

Conclusion