
By: Matthew Sturges (writer), Victor Ibáñez (artist), Ego (colorist)
The Story: Make no mistake, kids: collecting comics pays!
The Review: Even though The Spirit is of the old-school pulp/noir tradition, meaning it’s ostensibly a detective series at its heart, the actual detective work has been rather light on this run so far. David Hine made up for it by crafting tense dramas, where the mystery comes from the depth of the characters rather than the salient features of the plot. Still, it’d be quite a missed opportunity to not have the Spirit put his gumshoes back on at some point.
Sturges uses his one-shot, fill-in opportunity to full advantage by taking our hero back to his detective roots, which not only pays homage to the Spirit’s original conception, but also to the comics medium as a whole. Making a comic book writer (with a resemblance to Will Eisner himself—even the name, Lou Schleicher, has a familiar ring) and his “art” collection the heart of this issue not only sets up a fun premise, but speaks on what makes comics so beloved.
The trail of clues begins and leads along in old-school fashion: a dying man’s cryptic words, the hint in his unfinished work, the “red herring” (literally), and the answer right under your nose. The Spirit pieces them together in a fashion only an astute comics fan like him can (you can’t see Batman making these connections, brilliant as he is), so you not only feel the usual triumph that comes with these “mystery solved” moments, you also feel a rare sense of delight as well.
Our villains are mostly forgettable thugs (with shocking taste in what they consider art, seeing what they attempt to do to Mr. Schleicher’s treasures), but no Spirit comic would be complete without a compelling and bodacious broad, which Alabaster Cream definitely is. Sturges basically takes Bettie Page, an idol who influenced pin-ups the way Eisner did comics, puts her in glasses, and makes her a comics geek. It’s a character conception that couldn’t possibly fail, both disgustingly clever and fitting all at the same time.
Solid as Sturges’ script, it’s really Ibáñez’s art that makes this issue a comic of the highest caliber. DC should get smart and sign him immediately, because his work is what gives comic book art a good name. The level of detail he packs into each panel makes the Spirit’s world come alive almost cinematically. Just look at the props he puts into Alabaster’s mess-cat apartment: the Batman Lego figurine, a Dr. Fate cosplay helmet, the bear charm on her keychain. It’s worth mentioning he actually gives you two fully-developed, totally different kinds of art in this issue: one for the Spirit’s running story, and one for Mr. Schleicher’s Strongman comics.
Even more than these engaging details, Ibáñez delivers an outstanding artistry to his work. He uses blocked and free-form paneling as the occasion calls, but the flow of action always stays clear. His creative use of perspective brings retro-vitality to the story (though Ego’s pastel colors does just as much to sell the period look), but it also has a film director’s logic, like the top view of Alabaster showing off her comics pages on her table, and a close-up of those pages in the next panel. The one-page spread of the Spirit and Alabaster holding a conversation while traversing the sewers (no panel-blocks, mind you) couldn’t be more inspired if Eisner had drawn it himself.
Conclusion: This issue not only pays perfect tribute to The Spirit’s importance to the comics medium, it encapsulates the value of comics themselves to our culture in deeply enjoyable way—which is how good comics should be.
Grade: A
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – And the winner of Best Line About Comics in a Comic goes to: “Behold! The power of comics!”
– I definitely see Maus flying out as that comics box knocks into Proprio’s face, but can anyone identify the other covers?
Grade
Conclusion