By: Too many to list—check out the review.

The Story: Nothing like ten years in the slammer to make you appreciate being able to boogie freely again.

The Review: I got seriously into comics only a few years ago, so I had little to no familiarity with all the major names in the biz.  Dwayne McDuffie I only knew by name as writer of the terrific Static Shock and Justice League cartoons, and later by his unremarkable run on Justice League of America.  Until his messy exit from that title, I didn’t even know he was black; to me, he was a terrific writer of cartoons with an interesting, to say the least, history in comics.

So it is rather bittersweet to read this special, featuring his most famous creation and paying tribute to McDuffie himself.  The sweetness comes from the obvious love this issue’s creators has for him; the bitter arises from Felicia D. Henderson’s uninspired writing.  Better known for her television work, her biggest effort in comics was a polarizing stint on Teen Titans, which brings up the question of whether she was truly the best choice to take the lead on this special.

From the start, you encounter problems with featured character Teshomé Gabriel Hawkins, Static’s beloved uncle.  Henderson tries to paint him as sympathetic when he gets sent to prison unjustly for murder—presumably.  But she fails to delve into the case with any detail (you only know the victim gets killed Thanksgiving afternoon, and Teshomé shows up at Virgil’s house later that night for dinner), so you can only take Virg’s word that his uncle is innocent.

Henderson might still have pulled off Teshomé as a likable, worthy figure if she had given us more of his background beyond the fact that he’s a hustler.  If she had shown circumstances forced him into that sphere, and if she had revealed more of his redeeming virtues, you’d have more cause to believe in him.  But Henderson actually undermines Teshomé’s character by describing him as a “master of stolen goods”, and by having him show no excess of scruples when he says, “State wants to settle for ten mil.  Life’s good.  Life’s real good.”

There you have the tepid dramatic half of Henderson’s script; the super-heroic half is hardly better.  Besides some rushed, shoddy pacing (Teshomé knees his captor in one panel, and in the very next, he’s strapped down to a table), you also have to sit through some cringe-worthy dialogue: “It’s impolite to sneak up on a superhero…and seriously stupid.”  You also never see cocky thug Blinder as a real threat, since neither Static nor his uncle ever get in any real danger.

Perhaps it’s not worthwhile to discuss this next point, as it’s a throwaway line Teshomé delivers once (“A black man’s never free.”) and doesn’t really get picked up again later.  But it’s for that very reason I find it troubling.  Of course, blacks have every reason to see themselves as victims, but it’s that very tendency for self-victimization that frequently hinders progress.  The line’s emphasis on “never” clearly indicates no real expectation of better things.  All that’s left is to dish out resentment on others.

And that’s what you get in Matt Wayne’s tribute pages, a strangely strident series of statements from Virgil and Rocket (a character McDuffie created under Milestone Comics) as they address an unnamed figure who obviously meant to be their creator.  “Worst of all,” Rocket says, “people who despised you now get to tell your story.”  There’s clear anger in this scene, which seems an auspicious tone for a man’s comic-book obituary.

There’s a whole slew of artists working on this special, most of who contribute pin-up type pieces, but Denys Cowan gets to work on Henderson’s script, so his is the most prominent.  His rough, blocky style would’ve suited a straight-up gangster title perhaps, but is ill-suited for the superhero stuff, since he doesn’t do much justice to Static’s powers.  And there are panels where his lack of depth ruins the moment: in the opening pages, it looks like Teshomé is kissing thin air in front of Sharon, rather than her forehead.

Conclusion: Substantially and tonally, this special mostly goes against what you love about McDuffie: his attention to detail, his open-minded outlook on race, and his light-hearted tenderness.  He really deserved better.

Grade: D+

-Minhquan Nguyen

 

Grade

Conclusion