By: Jeff Lemire (writer), Pier Gallo (artist), Jamie Grant & Dom Regan (colorists)

The Story: Superboy and the Chamber of Secrets.

The Review: The moment Lemire launched this title, he injected a supernatural tone to the Smallville mythos that he many times said he would expand in time.  The Phantom Stranger’s multiple appearances heralded significant horrors to come for the Boy of Steel, but till now we’ve gotten radio-controlled frogs, time-traveling psychics, and plants from outer space.  Superboy seemed well on his way to joining his cousins in primarily sci-fi-based heroics.

Then this issue comes, and magic once again rears its unpredictable head, in the form of the Hollow Men, your classic creepy farmers with a twist of zombie.  This isn’t your usual Western European tradition of mysticism: witches and warlocks, nonsense words and fairy creatures.  Lemire takes a much more primal kind of magic and gives it a mad-scientist spin, a union that really suits the earthy, Midwestern backdrop of Smallville and Superboy’s scientific roots.

The arcane elements in this issue are equal parts alchemy, necromancy, and druidism, a perfect match for the eerie frontier of Smallville’s Wild West, the setting for Nathaniel Kent and Albert Valentine’s encounter with the town’s darker side.  It’s got all the stuff that makes great ghost stories: the banished Puritan doctor and his disturbed family; hidden spaces with macabre secrets; shudder-worthy murders; the inevitable building gone down in flames.

Like all great ghost stories, these details inevitably come back to haunt the real world once more, as the entire town falls into a stupor right before Connor’s eyes.  The answer lies of course in the “broken silo,” his only clue to the mysterious events of #2, and the place Nathaniel Kent found has more to it “than life and death,” in the words of crazed surgeon-occultist Eben Took.  Our payoff: the final splash showing what’s “below” Smallville, a stunner of a reveal if there’s any.

As the Phantom Stranger leads our heroes through this unnerving adventure, it’s worth noting Lemire’s compelling take on the character.  Mostly, P.S.’s cameos come with a strictly hands-off caveat, and his goals, though always obscure, seem to come from some higher cause.  The aggressive, even threatening vibe he gives off here, particularly towards Psionic Lad, definitely flies against his traditional portrayals, but it’s a good look on him.  His opening monologue also implies an intensely personal stake in this tale, which will be interesting to uncover later.

Speaking of Psionic Lad, Lemire doesn’t lose sight of that lurking plotline as he introduces even more wrinkles to the mix: there’s actually truth to the kid’s origins, as he once again reiterates he’s the only living superhuman left, which then throws into question exactly who’s the one transmitting orders to him from the future here.  More questions to keep in mind, I suppose.

This issue plays straight to Gallo’s strengths: the Wild West segment looks convincingly creepy, as does all the otherworldly moments he gets to draw in this story, making this title feel like the Supernatural of comics.  But he still can’t really pull off our main characters; he’s apparently better at drawing the older folks, as his amazing Phantom Stranger shows.

Conclusion: Lemire at last hits his stride on this title as he finally gets to play out the story he teased from the very beginning.

Grade: B+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – More than ever I want to see Karl Kerschl on interiors.  His last cover showed off his slick, youthful style, but the composition of this issue’s cover, with the white crows in the foreground and Stranger, one eye glinting, in the back, shows he can work the mature stuff too.

– Has there ever been a story where crows aren’t bad news?

 

Grade

Conclusion