
By: Jeff Lemire (creator), Jose Villarrubia (colorist)
The Story: “Shoot first, ask later” seems to be the rule of thumb in this world.
The Review: In my review of Fables #104, I mentioned the difficulties in jumping into the middle any series. So it was with some trepidation I waded into Sweet Tooth, which hasn’t really been around for that long and yet by most accounts has already taken on a rich life of its own. A couple people warned me the impact of the story would be lost without some familiarity with the ongoing plot. And so I expected to read the issue and come out completely puzzled.
It’s rather a waste to have all that concern over nothing, as Lemire makes this issue (as I suspect he makes every issue) quite a cinch to hop in with no prior knowledge whatsoever. While over on Superboy, I frequently noted the occasional blandness he gives the cast, the characters in his own title pop with vibrant personality: tough cynic Jepperd, strong-willed Lucy, antsy Dr. Singh. The moment they open their mouths, you get a firm grasp on who these people are.
Nowhere does this come through more clearly than in Lucy and Jepperd’s volatile interactions. Given how obviously tough each of them is (their fatally accurate marksmanship says as much), their relationship can’t be anything but edgy at the best of times, but it speaks volumes when he ventures, “You can’t really be mad at me?” For a gruff like Jepperd to be sensitive to Lucy’s feelings shows there’s a heart of gold beneath his rugged and scarred exterior.
Lemire also makes it easy to catch on not only to the overall plot (group on the run searching for sanctuary), but the major conflict at hand as well. This ragtag bunch has clearly been through some harrowing experiences on their journey, so the idea of finding sanctuary that much sooner no doubt poses serious temptations.
But the timing of it all seems a little too perfect to really trust haven-provider Walter’s motives. Though he insists to Jepperd and Lucy that the woodland rangers are dangerous, to get the duo to shoot the men from behind seems suspiciously hasty, as does persuading the group to come back to his place for the night before they think of investigating the bodies. In doing so, they miss a vital clue to their quest, as Lemire explicitly points out in the final panel.
Still, you should be convinced the group is safe as long as Jepperd and his acidic distrust of Walter are around, but the fact that he follows Walter’s lead in shooting down those mysterious men indicates he may not be as firmly unconvinced as he earlier claims. It’d be a twist to see Jepperd played the fool, especially in light of Dr. Singh’s belief that Jepperd may be the “White Demon” of Faunin’s Bible, though this conviction may stem from his increasing desperation to make sense out of his life of constant struggle.
With these kinds of dramatic, horror titles, a rough, sketchy style like Lemire’s works in a way that could never work with anything mainstream. Perhaps it’s the characters’ eyes—the way Lemire constantly depicts their whites, either bulging in shock or spread out from weariness, really emphasizes the anxious, perpetually fearful tension of the story.
Conclusion: Quite nearly as good as people make it to be, Sweet Tooth under Lemire’s hand easily takes you into the threatening quiet of its world, even if you’ve no familiarity with it whatsoever.
Grade: B+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Is anyone as sick of the Super 8 feature in the middle of every DC comic this week as I am? I admit, it reads and looks great with Peter Tomasi writing and Tommy Lee Edwards drawing, but it sure takes the wind out of a story’s sails to have to skip through a dozen pages to get to your next panel.
Grade
Conclusion