By: Judd Winick (writer), Hendry Prasetya (artist), Jessica Kholinne (colorist)

The Story: If he can make it rain, can we say it’s literally raining men?

The Review: Just because someone’s the star of the show doesn’t mean other people can’t take a turn in the spotlight now and then.  At a certain point along the road, you’ll find the lead just can’t sustain a consistent story output anymore.  But spotlighting a guest character requires some extra work; they really have to wind up making some lasting change to the story at large to make their temporary presence worthwhile.

So does Winick make the most out of Rayhan?  Well, his love of the character is obvious, as our Quraci friend gets quite a lot of solid scenes in the issue.  It seems the more down-to-earth the story, the better Winick gets at writing it, especially when it involves characters embracing their emotions.  Rayhan’s interactions with his father, both as a newly immigrated family and on his father’s deathbed, predictably pile on the sappiness, but you can’t deny the heart in them.

Actually, Rayhan’s unassailable virtues end up a kind of pitfall for the issue even as they esteem his strength of character.  He takes such extra pains to purposely not hurt anyone that the action never reaches the adrenaline-levels you’d expect from a brawl between a metahuman of his level (basically the male Storm) and a team-up of Batman and Power Girl.  The Dark Knight and the Mistress of Might do little more than chase after him in a distracted fashion the whole time.

As a result, our two established heroes become accessories to Rayhan’s story, which would be fine if you felt a real sense of resolution from his end.  But aside from some gratifying words from the duo that basically tried to keep him from seeing his dying father, you don’t get to see Rayhan get the justice he is due.  No one expects a Hollywood ending with Rayhan stepping down a courthouse in triumph into the sunset, but considering what his jailors put him through, a few vague promises of restitution fails to satisfy.

By the same token, we should’ve also seen P.G. introduce Rayhan to the Justice Society as she offers.  That scene would have both made Rayhan’s trials worthwhile and sell Kara and Bruce’s heartfelt moment at the issue’s end.  Instead, their talk comes off rather self-congratulatory (“Kara…you’re among the best, too.”  “Yeah…I am one of the best.”), which is just a tad laughable in the face of their enormous blunder.

Or two enormous blunders if you count letting Rayhan get put away in the first place.  Their suspension of trust in him still seems like an artificial tactic to prolong the story and add on to the wrongs Rayhan already has to deal with.  It just doesn’t seem possible Rayhan’s obvious acquiescence would be lost on their sense of fairness.

Prasetya’s clean, to-the-point work won’t get awards for boat-rocking creativity, but he gets the job done in polished fashion.  His real strength lies in his character work; he gives a little angularity and sharpness to the faces that instantly make them seem more dynamic.  Kholinne finally impresses with her colors as the previous washed-out quality is nearly all gone.

Conclusion: For such a controversial plot point, it lacks controversy, focusing on the emotional aspects of the story instead and doing so rather predictably.

Grade: B-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Who can offer me a reasonable explanation of how Rayhan manages to make it rain inside a building?

– Honestly, Kara, trying to use your heat vision to evaporate the rain is probably both the most futile and stupid tactic you’ve ever tried.  How about flying in a vortex counter to the hurricane’s spin to break up its force and then use your super-breath to dissipate it?

 

Grade

Conclusion