
By: J. Michael Straczynski & Chris Roberson (writers), Diogenes Neves, Oclair Albert, Eddy Barrows, JP Mayer, Jamal Igle, Jon Sibal (artists), Marcelo Maiolo (colorist)
The Story: This is a job for Superman! What? He’s not there? Leave a voicemail, I guess….
The Review: No matter how much you get into a superhero comic, at some point you’ll notice the faint tingle of suspended belief tingling at your amygdala (or whatever part of your brain matters of faith are located in—obviously I should never be anyone’s doctor or shrink). But keep it at bay you must, otherwise all sorts of uncomfortable questions about the logic and realism of what you’re reading will cow your simple pleasure into submission.
But when the writer himself chooses to address those questions, there’s really nothing you can do about it, is there? Fortunately, Roberson brings up several valid, thought-provoking issues that neatly ponder the implications of having a super-powered alien in our midst: the fear of his overwhelming might; whether he can be trusted to use his powers appropriately; the possible resentment from the mere mortals.
The subject matter works; the format which Roberson chooses to address these things does not. Characters telling stories within stories can be tricky to begin with, but in a comic, a bunch of brief, exemplary anecdotes just produces facts and details with little to no movement or substance whatsoever. Having Clark and his “guide” asking random passerby their opinions on Superman certainly adds no dramatic depth, and it just seems inherently forced.
Not to mention a lot of these passerby tales are cheesy enough to make really bad pizza. One that has already done a tour of mockery around the internet is Superman saving an Asian immigrant couple and their daughter’s cat. Instead of hearing my humble opinion on that little vignette, let’s hear it from the couple themselves: “We thank Heaven every day that he can do things we cannot do.” By which they mean, and I assume, getting a young feline out of a tree.
But really, the problem is this entire debate is entirely moot. Besides the person who weekly produces raving comments on my review of All-Star Superman (I like to think it’s Lex Luthor rabidly at work), almost no one takes issue with the Man of Steel, in the real or fictional world. Sure, as he’s proven in this very arc, he can be boring and nauseatingly self-righteous, but we forgive him because he’s at heart a good guy and few think otherwise.
Among those few is the mysterious stalker woman who’s been following Supes this whole time and has now decided to act, just at the moment Clark thinks he can go through life without a cape. Besides the unintended humor of seeing him immediately eat his half-baked conviction as soon as personal circumstances come into play, you get no feeling whatsoever from this obvious climactic spark. You know too little about her to care what she does, and anyway, with two months before this title resets itself, we all know Superman will take care of her in one issue.
With the script calling for mostly static, talky scenes, none of the artists on board get much to show off with, but all of them deliver competent work. Neves has the most dynamic style, using bold perspective choices and thin lines to create active, busy panels (love his interior shot of the Sundoller Coffee shop). but Barrows has never been a slouch in producing strong, secure character figures and expressions. The depth of Igle’s lines, inks, and curves change so often you sometimes feel there are several additional artists on this issue, ghost-drawing his work.
Conclusion: A rather unnecessary excursion into some old questions about Superman which never really gains much steam or interest.
Grade: C-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – In almost any real-life circumstance, that “guide” would and should be considered an obsessive creepo—a Superman otaku, if such a thing exists.
Grade
Conclusion