By: Tony Bedard (writer), Daniel HDR (penciller), Keith Champagne (inker), Nei Ruffino (colorist)

The Story: Love hurts…love scars…love wounds…and mars…

The Review: Boy, nothing quite like romantic squabbles to make for cheap yet reliable drama, huh?  A dose of it in can definitely spice up your fiction from time to time, though some people can handle far more than a dose.  I suspect for most of us, however, that kind of thing gets tiresome pretty fast.  As in real life, relationship craziness is often best left between the lovers, sparing bystanders from the awkward helplessness of something which ought to be personal.

That pretty much sums up the tense situation between Kyle and Soranik, a couple who have gone through plenty of turbulence together before, making their current rough patch seem forced.  It certainly does nothing for Sora’s credibility as a Lantern.  Personal issues have swayed other Lanterns’ behavior before, but in this issue, her lashing out (somewhat unjustly so) at Kyle in the middle of a firefight comes across unprofessional and borderline childish.

Since the animosity in their relationship seems entirely one-sided on Sora’s part, it makes sense Bedard would attempt to give her something worthy to get mad about with the revelation that Kyle lied about seeing her as his true love in Miri’s gem, some months earlier.  While deceiving Sora certainly wasn’t the wisest choice, Kyle’s reasons for doing so were reasonably, sincerely, even lovingly motivated, which should be as obvious to her as it is to us.

But the problems with this new wrinkle go beyond undermining Kyle as boyfriend material.  For one, it renders the Star Sapphires’ powers as completely pointless.  After all, they base their whole existence around identifying and protecting true love.  If they can get it wrong, that would pretty much make their entire purpose in the universe moot.  Besides, with Kyle’s “true love” at the time fatally out of the picture, did that mean he only had the choice of never moving on from his old flame forever, or taking on a new love that was “untrue”?

None of these issues begin to rival the senselessness of Miri’s actions this issue, all evidence tha the entire corps of Star Sapphires is one hot dog short of a combo platter.  That their devotion to preserving one great romance (or, in this case, half of one) could entail the destruction and havoc of an entire world, thereby endangering presumably hundreds to thousands of other equally devoted lovers, is just plain nuts.  At least it keeps within the Sapphire tradition of insanity.

HDR offers very plain, passable art, giving us the bare minimums of dynamism and emotional depth to let the scenes slide by, but otherwise doing nothing to deliver an outstanding look for the issue.  If you need an example of this lifelessness, look no further than the panel where Tomar-Tu and Kyle fall out of Miri’s space portal.  From quite a ways up in the air, Kyle lands face-first on what appears to be a patch of flaming stone, but his body position looks more like a handstand gone awry, his face appearing glued to the ground.  His spoken reaction: “Oof.”  This could not have succeeded in underwhelming more had HDR planned it.

Conclusion: Mostly shrill, bitter, strident, or weary in tone, this issue shows in rather senseless execution that true love isn’t all it’s cracked up to be.

Grade: C

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Tomar-Tu’s Zen attitude affords him more patience and tolerance for Kyle and Natu’s antics than I ever could.  My every instinct is to yell at them, “Would the former sex partners please cut out their moronic couple’s spat long enough to give me a hand with this other ridiculous idiot?”

– Come on, Miri—you’re wearing a pink, bejeweled tiara, for God’s sake.  How the heck am I supposed to take you seriously?

Grade

Conclusion