
By: Robert Kirkman (writer), Charlie Adlard (art), Cliff Rathburn (gray tones), Rus Wooton (letterer) & Sina Grace (editor)
The Story: Life goes on in the Alexandria compound now that someone has woken up from a coma.
What’s Good: As with all Walking Dead reviews I do, this review contains SPOILERS….
Honestly, there isn’t a whole lot to really cheer in this issue. There is a nice little bit of Andrea as she fends of an unwelcome romantic advance. This sort of love triangle is just what would probably happen in any small, closed environment. I’d bet that the Alexandria compound doesn’t have a perfectly 50/50 ratio of eligible men and women, so some folks aren’t going to make a love connection. Beyond the biological imperatives that these folks might be feeling, sometimes it would be nice to just have some companionship, ya know? And, you can only imagine the potential violent messes that could arise from unrequited romantic feelings in this pressure cooker! Chalk this up as another trademark Kirkman “slow burn”.
It was also just generally interesting to see the folks getting to work, scouting the immediate area, planning for the future, etc. One of the interesting things about any post-apocalypse story is seeing how humanity tries to put the pieces back together and we haven’t gotten any of that in TWD in years.
The art is also a plus on this issue. There is really zero showing off by Adlard; just good solid comic storytelling.
What’s Not So Good: What a half-measure Carl’s amnesia is! After the final-page reveal last issue that he didn’t remember that his mother was dead, there was a WORLD of possibilities here and Kirkman took the least interesting: That Carl merely couldn’t remember his mother’s death, but could remember most other things. It would have been really fascinating to just hit the reset button on Carl and get to explore what would happen to a kid who is just dropped into the middle of the TWD world and along the way have him regain snippets of his memories (like the folks he’s killed). Major missed opportunity!
One area where I usually heap praise on TWD is for how hard Kirkman works to make each single issue worthwhile by giving it a bit of a cliffhanger instead of just churning out blah single issues in pursuit of a nice trade paperback. But, in this case, he kind of fumbles the ending. It’s very uncharacteristic for him, but this just wasn’t as good of an ending as we’re used to seeing. The scene I wanted to see was the Rick/Andrea scene where Andrea comes upon Rick crying. That scene seemed like it needed one more panel, but we didn’t get it and instead jumped back to a confusing and not very well introduced scene back at the compound of some malcontents plotting against Rick. Even though it’s making clear that trouble was brewing, it wasn’t the ending I wanted on this issue.
There was also no Michonne action in this issue at all. She’s been built up a lot the last few issues as she grows closer to Rick and deals with her feelings since Morgan’s death. But in this issue, she barely gets a line of dialog.
Conclusion: Not the hottest issue, to be honest. Maybe launching a new comic series (The Infinite), having a second season of TWD coming up on TV with all the hooplah around Frank Darabont getting fired, having a TWD novel coming out, having a TWD board game coming out and having a TWD video game in development (in addition to writing Invincible) is taking it’s toll? This issue isn’t “bad”, but it is mostly uneventful and features some storytelling that doesn’t sit quite right.
Grade: C
-Dean Stell
Follow Dean on Twitter.
Grade
Conclusion