By: Matthew Sturges (writer), Hendry Prasetya (artist), Jessica Kholinne (colorist)

The Story: You’ll have to excuse Power Girl; she doesn’t usually make waves.

The Review: If you’ve ever taken a philosophy or ethics class, you’ve no doubt experienced the fictional, but strangely fraught and disturbing perils of the hypothetical question.  You were likely asked to choose between two equally awful actions, and the moral acrobatics you take to do so will probably make your soul curl into a fetal position.  As the titular character from Jasper Fforde’s Thursday Next says, “The only way to win the game is not to play.”

Power Girl takes that advice to heart in her last issue, which works on the ol’ ticking-clock gambit, the meatier sibling of the hypothetical question: some villain sets into motion a series of conflicts for the hero to handle in a limited time frame, both to ensure failure at some point and to test the hero’s priorities.  Karen, being no dummy and stranger to this kind of ploy, rises to the challenge by changing the rules of the game.

The success of these kinds of plots usually land fifty-fifty.  Some turn out truly tense stories which place the characters into some shady gray areas (see Secret Six #19), and others produce a functional story, no more.  This one easily lands in the latter category.  Suspense is impossible if the character in question feels no danger, and at no point, really, does P.G. even entertain the notion that she might fail—and neither do we.

So the only real entertainment to be had here is seeing the hoops she must fly through to get things done, and how she does it.  Unfortunately, our mastermind sets probably the least threatening obstacles in her way possible, including a werewolf and luchadore duo whom Karen accurately calls the “Laurel and Hardy of costumed criminals,” a muscleman named Da’ Bomb, and some Red Tornado-like gray dude who is actually a carrot-topped goon when depowered.

Granted, all comics operate on the suspension of logic in some way, particularly if superpowers come into play.  But I have to take issue with the allotted time to get all these things done, somewhere around fifty seconds.  This is ridiculous even by Power Girl’s standards, but it really only grows into a problematic logistical hole when Cyclone gets involved, because as far as I know, Maxine Hunkel has no power to get from Brazil to the Philippines in twenty-five seconds.

On top of all that, this whole mess comes to nothing, as it merely preludes the first step to a much grander scheme that now we will never see anyway.  Power Girl may have passed this test with flying colors, but she gains and learns nothing by doing so, which seems a pretty pointless direction for a character’s last accomplishment before cancellation.

Prasetya’s manga influence suits this light, unassuming story very well, though it can’t be said he ever goes above and beyond the line of duty where detail is concerned.  While the simplicity of his style makes the issue easily digestible, it also emphasizes the superficial quality of the story, turning the Leaning Tower of Pisa so smooth and regular in appearance that it looks more like an elaborately decorated cake than a piece of architectural wonder.

Conclusion: Ultimately, the final issue goes nowhere and leaves our hero stranded at a dead end, but honestly, such a finish is poetic considering this title never had much direction to begin with.

Grade: C+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – And if anyone wants to contest my assertion of Prasetya’s neglectful eye to detail, I’d like to point out the lack of freckles on Cyclone’s face.  It’s the little things.

– Seriously—stupid cats.  I swear they make up half of our heroes’ workloads.  Which of them hasn’t had to drag some dumb feline out a tree at some point?

Grade

Conclusion