
By: Kelly Sue DeConnick (writer), Chriscross (penciller), Marc Deering (inker), Blond (colorist)
The Story: Think Ghostbusters meets the Goonies, with a splash of the Breakfast Club.
The Review: In my review of Zatanna #13, I mentioned that a supporting cast can really make a title, a point worth elaborating. No matter how strong a star, they can’t carry an entire issue on their backs all the time. Getting a few other people into the mix breaks up the story, keeps you from stalling in one place for too long, and adds any number of possibilities to send the plot into an unexpectedly wonderful direction.
DeConnick clearly understands the value of giving everyone something important to do, even the ones who probably (well, definitely—this is the end of the line for the series, after all) will never show up again. Even though Professor Ivo’s bank of the absolute finest genetic potential humanity has to offer doesn’t really go anywhere out of the ordinary, the story zips along and keeps you interested, in no small part due to the antics of the non-capes in this issue.
Remember, you have a crew of geeky geniuses (the two things aren’t always synonymous), and they’re in a sewer with a bunch of mechanical junk lying around. Put them together, and you have a pump capable of funneling sewage water to drown a pack of robotic rats, and several stun guns with various vacuum cleaner attachments for their muzzles. Now you have a Supergirl rescue squad, which means the threshold for danger gets that much higher.
But a support crew can do so much more than provide some laughs (“Lady, we were born ready.”) and spectacle. Some, like Ngoze, the tall, afro-headed campus guide from #65, become valuable, sympathetic figures. We can all appreciate the frustration of always coming in second, and the vain wish that the first-place finisher would just disappear. But Ngoze takes her wish to heart when it inadvertently comes true, and her desire to make up for it proves integral to Lois’ quest for justice and shows sometimes, it’s the runner-ups that gain victory in the end.
Henry Octavius Flyte learns the converse lesson; shaken and properly chastened from his close shave to vegetable-hood, a situation his own cockiness got himself into, he realizes being first chair doesn’t guarantee hit music. It’s refreshing to see a character accept his comeuppance so openly, and honestly, the “just some guy” look suits him a lot more than “bastard ne’er do well,” which, to my encouragement, results in a pretty sweet moment with Kara at the end.
With so much focus placed on other characters, Supergirl becomes less of a star and more the center of an ensemble, a position which suits her, given her personality as a straight man. But signs point to a brighter future, as she begins to come out of her shell and show that beneath that deadpan exterior lies an irresistible otaku wit (her description of Ivo: “Like a horny toad at a Gundam convention.”). Too bad we won’t get to see it happen
Chriscross always had a very fluid, malleable quality to his art, distending the faces and bodies of his characters for the most comic effect, which works in a youthful title with a nerdy spin. But here he occasionally takes that quality to the point of distraction; Shirley looks like a forty-year-old trying to pass as seventeen, and if Supergirl’s lips are any indication, she must have no problem fitting an entire fist in her mouth.
Conclusion: No disrespect to Sterling Gates’ respectable run on this title, but DeConnick delivers quite possibly the best take on Supergirl in years, a taste of the series we might have, could have, should have had all along.
Grade: A-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Check out our interview with the witty, warm, and wise Kelly Sue DeConnick here and here. We will watch her career with great interest.
– You know when Shirly goes, “Pew pew pew pew!” while shooting her stun gun? Instant flash to Tina Fey doing Sarah Palin in the mock Katie Couric interview on SNL. Classic.
Grade
Conclusion