By: Geoff Johns (writer), Jim Lee (penciller), Scott Williams (inker), Alex Sinclair (colorist)

The Story: I have only one question—what happened to everybody’s underwear?

The Review: Funny.  It doesn’t feel like a new age of comics.  But DC insists one has come, and seeing the enormous slate they’ve just wiped clean, we must take their word for it.  This relaunch sets out to reinvigorate their company line as a whole, and also invite a whole new audience to the table.  So suppose I was a virgin comics reader, convinced to pay for this glimpse into the wonders of the DCU.  Does the issue convince me this world is worth my time and imagination?

Of course, just because you’re a virgin doesn’t mean you have zero experience of what you’re about to get into.  Movies have made certain figures familiar, even household names, and DC heroes are icons to begin with.  Small wonder we begin with the most recognizable and current of those: Batman, Green Lantern, and, of course, Big Blue himself (even more blue now that his underpants have been removed—from sight, anyway).

For those of us all too familiar with the many iterations of these heroes, their characterizations may seem raw and shallow indeed.  G.L. has all his trademark cockiness (“Note to self, Batman: Green Lantern can handle anything.”) and Batman comes across less gritty than just plain grouchy (“Take your flashlight and go home.”).  But from the eyes of a new reader, the scenes effectively show us the characters’ core personalities, powers, and mission statement.

We also get a nice introduction to Vic Stone, of Cyborg fame, one of the more exciting choices for the League, as he adds not only diversity to the team, but youth.  Make no mistake, this Cyborg is greener than Green Lantern, as at the onset, he has no cybernetic accessories (not even a laser canon!) to speak of.  But as the freshest face on this title, he’ll serve an important role as our guide to this updated universe, and the herald of its new generation of go-getters.

We should take some time to discuss the story’s structure.  You have two schools of thought for how to launch a team: gather them up and let them at it, or just get into the thick of things and ask questions later.  John goes for the former, and executes it well, but he doesn’t quite succeed in producing an immediately striking issue.  He gets burdened with having to introduce everyone to us and to each other, and that makes for slow going on the plot itself.

Each character interaction or intro essentially stalls the action, and the world at large remains hidden from us.  We have only a vague idea of what our leading conflict will be, though we can safely assume it’ll have cosmic proportions (“Ping”).  The issue really only manages to give us a promising storyline with some interesting characters, but hardly the groundbreaker you’d expect

Lee won’t get awards for inspired storytelling artistry, but he is a crowd-pleaser.  You can’t deny his appeal: the lush settings, the confident, energetic strides of his lines, his blockbuster sense of paneling, and the sheer boldness of his character designs.  He’s refined out most of the superfluous qualities from his early work, so what he does now looks eye-catching (in no small part thanks to Sinclair’s colors), but still tasteful.

Conclusion: Here’s my fresh-eyed, baby-faced impression.  It may capture my interest enough to keep me following the title, in a “wait and see” kind of way, but it doesn’t quite succeed in me to empty my wallet for the slew of new titles and characters very soon to come.

Grade: B

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Equally heated as the Wonder Woman pants/no pants debate is the question of Superman’s underwear: outside or inside?  Call me irreligious, but I happen to think the underpants outside thing was always at least a little dumb even when it was popular, and never failed to make DC’s biggest hero look somewhat goony.  Consider this my vote for his new look.

Grade

Conclusion