
By: Scott Snyder (writer), Greg Capullo (pencils), Jonathan Glapion (inks), FCO Plascencia (colors), Richard Starkings & Jimmy Betancourt (letters), Katie Kubert (assistant editor), Janelle Asselin (associate editor) & Mike Marts (editor)
The Review: All the “in the know” comic fans had really high hopes for this issue because it is (a) written by Scott Snyder who is fresh off the best Bat-story of the last decade or so and has never written a bad comic in his life and (b) drawn by Greg Capullo who is one of the best and most underappreciated artists in the comic industry.
This is an outstanding comic book. Not only is it a wonderful comic for fans who have read hundreds of Batman comics, but I think it’ll also be accessible to new readers. Of course, only a moron doesn’t know who Batman is, but they might not know who his rogues are and who all the supporting characters are. So…. Snyder takes us on a quick who’s-who of Gotham residents. And he does it all within the context of his story and using a nifty bit of new technology that makes the introductions better than mere caption boxes. That’s what I really love about Snyder: He never takes the easy way out with his writing. By the end of the issue, you know the players, what they’re like and where they fit in Gotham. I hate to compare to other titles, but when you look at how much ground Snyder covers in this issue, it really makes Justice League #1’s pacing seem sloth-like.
Oh, and in addition to all of that, we get our first mystery too. The story looks to be a little twisted and knowing Snyder’s facility with horror-ish material, I’m really looking forward to the next issue.
There are also all kinds of bones thrown to long-time readers. For example, the Bat-cave has Dick and Damian’s flying Batmobile. So, that’s still there. We also get a really neat group shot of Bruce, Dick Grayson, Tim Drake and Damian Wayne in one picture that illustrates how they’re all slightly different ages, but that they’re all one family and all have “high” level access to the Bat-systems. Of course, the coolest thing is when we learn that Alfred has “highest” level access: As much as Dick/Tim/Damian are family to Bruce, Alfred is his real father-figure and truest partner, so it makes sense that he’d be the most trusted.
Everyone who has enjoyed Greg Capullo on titles like Spawn and Haunt felt kinda bittersweet when we heard he was leaving to do some vague Bat-book last year (we now understand why everyone was so dodgy about what title he’d be drawing since the new 52 hadn’t been announced). On one hand, we’d miss him on Haunt, but we were all also looking forward to shoving this Batman #1 issue in the faces of all our comic buddies who were skeptical about “that Spawn guy” drawing the Bat. We knew this would be awesome and it is. Capullo is an incredibly gifted visual storyteller and his slightly cartoony style allows him to capture all this little quirks of body language that help us see what is going on. But, Capullo also has enough grit in his style that Batman never comes off as silly. I just love it.
A couple panels really stand out. One is the aforementioned family photo showing Bruce, Dick, Tim and Damian. You know how many artists can’t manage to make teenage characters look teenaged? Well, Capullo just shows off here by drawing a hulking Bruce who looks to be in his early 30’s, Dick being a grown 22-ish year old (but still slender), Tim looking very 16 and Damian looking just like the murderous 10 year old that he is. Wow! I don’t even want to think what this original page would cost. Then there are a few other panels early on in the issue where Batman is fighting side-by-side with a certain villain who is remarkably acrobatic. At first I thought he was just being redefined as a more nimble guy, until we learn later in the issue that there was a very good reason why he was springing around like that. Great stuff!
The only bad thing for DC is that I’m going to be perfectly happy reading just this Bat-book. I don’t need Detective Comics, Batman & Robin, Batwing, Batgirl, Catwoman, Nightwing, etc… This is such an excellent book that it makes those others look very pedestrian.
Conclusion: This is the best of the new 52 issues I’ve read so far. With a creative team like this title has, we should be in for an outstanding run on this new Batman. I can’t wait!
Grade: A
-Dean Stell
Grade
Conclusion