By: Warren Ellis (writer), Kev Walker (art), Frank Martin (colors), Dave Lanphear (letters), Lauren Sankovitch (associate editor) & Tom Brevoort (editor)

The Story: The Secret Avengers learn about some secret weapon being transported through Eastern Europe and mobilize to take it down.

What’s Good: This done-in-one story format is so great.  Get in there, tell the damn story and move on to the next story.  It is such a nice thing to be reminded that a comic story can be begun and ended in a single issue.  What’s funny is that you can totally see how some other writers at Marvel could stretch this issue’s idea into a 6-month saga by adding lots of “character moments” to a dude like Steve Rogers who has been around since the 60’s.  When I see a guy like Ellis just pumping out a series of done-in-ones like he’s doing Secret Avengers, I just imagine him laughing at those 6-issue arc guys and laughing because he has ideas like this dripping from every orifice on his body.

What makes done-in-ones so great is that even if they suck or if you don’t like the mix of characters the creators choose, it’s over in ~20 minutes instead of dragging for 6-months.  And because the pain of a bad idea is over faster, it can encourage creators to be more experimental, and isn’t that a good thing?
This story kicks off so well.  The Secret Avengers detect a threat, Steve rallies a team of whoever is in the building at the time and whatever quinjet is in the parking garage and off they go.  It feels like a real emergency since they aren’t waiting around for Black Widow or Beast to show up.  Have we ever seen a 4-person team of Steve, Sharon Carter, War Machine and Valkyrie?  I don’t know that we have and that’s cool.  I probably wouldn’t want to read an ongoing series with just these characters, but it’s great for an issue.

Big fan of Kev Walker.  I don’t think this work is quite as good as what he’s been doing on Thunderbolts, but I don’t think this particular story maximizes what makes him really unique in that he can draw just about any size/type/shape of character.  But all the art is attractive and energetic which is my major desire in superhero art.

What Isn’t Quite As Good: I couldn’t quite get my arms around the threat in this issue.  The robo-zombies were cool (and funny), but I really didn’t get what was in the truck.  It seemed like either Ellis needed to do a better job of telling us about the threat or Walker needed to do a better job showing us.  Even though this is my only complaint, it’s a pretty big one because it really did hamper my enjoyment of this particular issue.

Conclusion: These issues since Ellis took over are just what Secret Avengers needed.  They read just like his Global Frequency series set in the Marvel Universe.  Even though this issue missed a little bit, it doesn’t squelch my enthusiasm one iota.

Grade: C (with a bullet)

-Dean Stell

Follow Dean on Twitter.

Follow WCBR on Twitter and Facebook.

Grade

Conclusion