
By: Scott Lobdell (writer), Brett Booth (penciller), Norm Rapmund (inker), Andrew Dalhouse (colorist)
The Story: All they want are some BFFs they can count on—to fight evil secret cabals with.
The Review: Of all the new DC titles, perhaps the one with the most controversy attached is Teen Titans. The concern most people have, I suspect, is how a largely unknown writer will handle not only one of DC’s biggest properties, but also some of the most iconic characters in the DCU. The Titans may be sidekicks, but they’re also incredibly popular in their own right. No one wants to see them “reimagined” to the point where we can’t recognize them anymore.
On that point, Lobdell exercises considerably more restraint that you might have feared. With Red Robin and Kid Flash, at least, he doesn’t make any radical changes to their characters. Both come with fairly well-developed personalities and back-story, thanks to past ongoings, so there’s no real reason to mess with what already works, and Lobdell wisely doesn’t.
Superboy and Wonder Girl are different stories. I’ve already talked about the inconsistency in Superboy’s portrayals, and Wonder Girl fares no better, especially since she’s never had a single ongoing dedicated to her name. These two can definitely stand to use some tweaking in their conceptions, but it’s hard to say if Lobdell’s take truly gives them the lift they need.
You can’t tell at this point if turning Wonder Girl into a rough-talking felon will do much to reinvigorate her character, but at least it engages you more than the morose girl with a poorly hidden inferiority complex we used to get on J.T. Krul’s version of the Titans. And anyway, Lobdell doesn’t take her over the top; her sullen attitude may run against your usual idea of her, but at least it makes sense given the explosive circumstances in which she appears.
“Explosive” seems a fitting word, since this issue gives us three explosions, each in completely separate scenes. The title sets itself at the dawn of the superhero sidekick, and you can bet the unrefined combo of unpredictably impulsive teenagers with the volatile vigilante lifestyle will result in some fairly combustible situations. None of this plotline is new—both the original Young Justice series and Young Avengers covered this ground—so we can all easily predict that sooner or later our scrappy kid heroes will win the trust and respect they deserve.
But on top of this old yarn, Lobdell adds N.O.W.H.E.R.E. (a torturous acronym even by comics standards), a covert group out to either nip young crime-fighters in the bud or, as in Red Robin’s case, recruit them for their own purposes. Again, not exactly a novel premise, but it does give the formation of the team an interesting spin. The soon-to-be Titans are less about finding kindred spirits, and more about seeking protection as a group before they get put down.
We can understand why Booth got picked for this job; he has very keen, deft lines that take well to the agile movements of the young characters, and he does deliver some great detail (love Red Robin’s spread of holo-news panels featuring other sidekick sightings). But his penchant for hyper-narrow faces and overly busy costumes are often visually distracting, sapping your focus from what would otherwise be a pretty decent script.
Conclusion: With all the negative talk that preceded this title, the issue actually feels stronger than what you’d lowered yourself to expect. Still, you’ll have good reason to stay a little wary, as it’ll take a couple issues to determine if the character changes will ultimately work out.
Grade: C+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – As a tiny scribble on Red Robin’s holographic corkboard indicates, this Kid Flash is indeed meant to be Bart Allen. Where that leaves Wally West (who still hasn’t appeared or been mentioned in any shape or form), we don’t know.
– And yet all four of Batman’s Robins (that’s a TV show right there, folks) accounted for, you’d think there’d be enough room for one more Flash, kid or otherwise.
– Good Lord, Red Robin’s wings are obnoxious—and make no sense. How they can be aerodynamic, metallic, and bullet-proof at the same time, I have no clue.
Grade
Conclusion