
By: Peter Milligan (writer), Mikel Janin (artist), Ulises Arreola (colorist)
The Story: Madame Xanadu, you are being a major downer right now.
The Review: Some words come with major connotative baggage attached, which people don’t always realize when they use them. I’d say “dark” falls in this category. Lately, you hear writers drop this word a lot in plugging their projects, as if by doing so their work will instantly take on a layer of “seriousness.” Instead, they usually only succeed in sapping “dark” of all its meaning. Nowadays, the mere mention of it elicits only a shrug and eye-roll.
DC went full-on trigger-happy with the word, creating a whole line of books under the “dark” umbrella. Luckily, they have skilled writers onboard to give credit to the description, and Milligan is no exception. You don’t get much darker than a two-page splash of a bunch of identical women on a highway, each in various stages of getting maimed by speeding vehicles.
This can all be gratuitous if it has no reason for being other than to shock you. Milligan keeps his grimly imaginative ideas grounded in a steady plot and character-developing moments, unless he’s using them to set tone. Like John Rozum on Xombi, he has a knack for laying out a series of visuals for gut-hitting impression: “…cows give birth to mechanical meat slicers…the power station threatens to explode when it is imbued with consciousness…and gets bored.”
At the heart of all this strangeness, inside a glowing-green envelope where “time itself slows down,” and “Neutrons crush inside atoms,” lies Enchantress. For a while, over in the now defunct Shadowpact, she demonstrated remarkable self-control, but now she seems totally unhinged at last, going the way of Scarlet Witch and magically lashing out against all who approach her maddened state. Included among her victims are several members of the Justice League, with Superman realizing he’s no match against the cuts of “Filthy flying teeth!”
As always when the League runs into a supernatural matter even they can’t handle, they turn to Zatanna, resident magician. This version of Zee seems more self-assured, unhesitant about taking charge in her realm of expertise, but she also remains clear-eyed about who she’s about to take on. She refuses Batman’s help, saying, “…the world just can’t afford to lose you. Me, I reckon it could get along just fine without.”
But not to worry; she’ll soon have good company to take on an insane witch. We have John Constantine, who retains his usual wily ways (“…I was scamming this rich geezer [who] wanted to contact his dead wife. I wanted to pay my rent.”). We also have Shade, the Changing Man, as well-intentioned and twisted as ever. There’s Deadman, who gets paid a visit by Enchantress’ blond alter-ego, June Moone. And then we have Madame Xanadu, who sees nothing but crows and skeletons in our heroes’ (and the world’s) future.
Janin’s art goes a bit stiff on the action, but luckily, people who work magic are showmen by nature and trade, so the ultra-posed look works. He should rein in his expressions just a bit, as they go somewhat soap-operaish in a few places (why is Batman smiling for no reason in that one panel with Zee?). Overall, though, Janin brings all the horrific elements of the issue to life—so to speak—especially with Arreola’s moody coloring, trimmed with unnerving glows.
Conclusion: Inserting “dark” into the book’s title obviously subjects it to a pretty heavy burden, but in this case, Milligan does a good job living up to it. DC has some of the best occult figures in comics; putting them all in the same comic, so far, seems a pretty smart move.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Weirdly, the most emotional moment of the issue is when Kathy, Shade’s “girlfriend,” realizes she’s a mere creation of his loneliness and begins to dissolve from the knowledge: “…s-so you conjure me and then put me through [all this pain]? A-m I even real? H-have I ever truly existed?”
Grade
Conclusion