By: Ethan Van Sciver & Gail Simone (writers), Yildiray Cinar (artist), Steve Buccellato (colorist)

The Story: Where racial tension goes nuclear!

The Review: Consider this a bit of a love letter to Simone, but really, what is there not to love about the woman?  She went from geek-feminist blogger on comics to one of the finest, most respected writers in the biz.  True, she may not be a hit-factory in the sense of the thousands-sellers Geoff Johns or Grant Morrison produce, but she has given us such critically tremendous series that you’re willing to give any title she writes a shot, even one about Firestorm.

Here, we have two of Firestorm’s most prominent possessors: Ronnie Raymond and Jason Rusch.  That sets up Simone with the double burden of having to get through two protagonists’ back histories, and giving both important things to do.  It’s one thing to split the duties among an ensemble cast, but having two stars can get pretty complicated.  If one of them happens to break out, and the other doesn’t, now you have a series with dead weight that’s impossible to hide.

But so far, the two young men pose equal interest.  In a none-too-subtle upturn of racial stereotyping, we get Ronnie as the devoted athlete with average smarts, and Jason as the brain who bristles around jocks.  As you might expect, the two butt heads from the first page they meet, though truthfully, Jason comes in ready to think the worst.  Once Ronnie fails to offer the most scintillating comment to Jason’s interview for the school paper, it falls apart from there.

Quite naturally, the race card gets pulled out, which never leads anywhere productive, but makes for good drama.  Jason lists damning statistics (“…in a school with 45% of the students being African American, there hasn’t been a black quarterback…”), while Ronnie falls back on a typical white man’s guilty defensiveness (“Those guys are my brothers.”).  If you have any experience in spats of racial matters, the scene definitely has the ring of truth to it.

Still, all this is merely the more uncomfortable subjects of mundane life.  For the truly gnarly scenes, look to the merry band of killers searching the world for magnetic bottles containing secrets to creation itself.  In Simone’s trademark grimness, the three sadists show no qualms about slaying an entire family of Turkish innocents, blowing up the entire block, blaming the boy they murder as a terrorist, and quoting scripture as they do it (see Philippians 4:13).

So far, so good—until you get towards the climax of the issue, where the plot half unwinds thanks to Ronnie’s complete meltdown (non-nuclear, this time), screaming senselessly at Jason, “…you…made fun of my hair,” while the people actually trying to kill them plan to blow up their school.  Of course, Ronnie’s freakout makes some sense, given the circumstances, but that doesn’t change the inherently cheesy quality of his ravings.

Cinar does a dependable job as always, his art taking on a slightly more grounded tone with Buccellato’s pastel style of colors.  The only real beef to be made is with the design of Fury, whose crackling streaks of energy and skullish face means to come across foreboding, but whose titanic body makes him look kind of ridiculous, like a bootied, vested Hulk.

Conclusion: While still iffy about the characters, Simone convinces you there’s potential here, which is far more than many a writer have done.

Grade: C+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Please tell me that from now on, every transformation has to be accompanied with a preceding shout of “Firestorm!” in the tradition of “SHAZAM!”  No matter how good the series may become, I don’t think I can handle that, issue after issue.

Grade

Conclusion