By: Fabian Nicieza (writer), Pete Woods (artist), Brad Anderson (colorist)

The Story: Can’t we just talk, energy-being to energy-being?

The Review: I’ve noticed in reviews of the two new titles featuring the Legion of Super-Heroes that folks mostly take issue with the inaccessibility of the team itself.  Like many DC properties, the Legion has a very dense, complicated history, but unlike many DC properties, it’s had to reinvent itself from the ground up at least a couple times, arguably more.  The team has tons of characters, each with a long, complex background, and a rather specific setting.

Any one of these points by itself would make Legion pretty obtuse to readers, but put them all together and you have yourself a surefire niche title, one existing mostly for the pleasure of its small band of devotees and hardly anyone else.  If Legion’s to have any chance of expanding its audience, it needs winning stories by top-notch writers and artists, and it needs it now.

Nicieza is a top-notch writer.  His work on both Robin and Red Robin demonstrated a high bar for quality titles featuring young characters.  He has a great ear for first-person, semi-stream-of-consciousness narration, and he shows it through Wildfire’s description of events this issue.  He mixes exposition with character bits (“No, really, Wolf, try stopping an energy-based form with a chunk of wood.  More sprockin’ stubborn than I am…”), reading naturally and engagingly.

Unfortunately, a lot of the narration gets wasted on the same set of expository points: Alastor, an alien of the future, enraged at the death of his sister from Earth’s xenophobia, goes back in time to “our” present day to infect humanity with a virus that will transform them all into mutant hybrids.  Not only did the debut cover this ground already, but this issue actually goes through this whole spiel twice, meaning you’re already feeling worn out from half the plot in two issues.

Even more problematic, the amount of time spent describing and re-describing this chain of events takes away time that should have been spent on illustrating the life of our hybrid-human (“Hypersapien,” the book calls it) of the month.  Doctor Scanlon’s fixation with his newly-received powers supposedly veils an even deeper self-loathing and despair (“I stopped being human long before this happened!” he yells), but we never once learn any specifics about it, making the issue’s climactic end lose most of its emotional weight.

If Nicieza wants to go forward with this “monster of the month” system of writing, he’ll have to figure out a way to more efficiently get us in tune with the Hypersapien in question and allow more opportunities for the cast to interact.  Most of the Legion’s appeal comes from their rich chemistry, and we need to see more of that, like Drake and Dawny’s banter: “…I sure wish our mission team had included a few more science-types…”  “You were an astrophysics major…”  “Yeah, bottom of my class too.”

At least you can’t complain about Woods’ art, in tandem with Anderson’s bright, glossy colors.  It’s still pretty amazing how easily Woods altered his style to suit the more youthful, adventurous tone of this title, yet still retaining its inherent capacity for drama.  Check out how Dr. Scanlon’s face gradually creases then relaxes as the implications of his new nature sinks in.  It really brings out the emotional core of the writing (a good thing, since a lot of it gets truncated).

Conclusion: In comparison to the nearly manic first issue, the second stalls trying to reestablish the groundwork for its premise and give an example of the series’ direction to come.  Let’s hope, for the sake of Legion’s future popularity, this is only one hump for the title’s course.

Grade: B-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – I hope Nicieza will cool it with the “____ Hours After Release” captions soon, because they’re getting as annoying as all the Legion roll call captions that usually plague Legion titles.

Grade

Conclusion