
By: Jonathan Hickman (writer), Dustin Weaver (artist), Sonia Oback (colorist)
The Story: The property rates are just gonna plummet after this, aren’t they?
The Review: The pace of release for this series has just gotten into joke territory, hasn’t it? Two months between issues is simply way too long. When you take a step back and look at the figures, it means that in one year, the title releases six issues, about the length of a single story arc. Unless that arc is completely groundbreaking and/or stellar, there is almost no way such a title can expect long term success or pull with its audience.
Unfortunately, this story arc (which basically continues the plot from S.H.I.E.L.D.’s last volume, crazy as it sounds) has been neither groundbreaking nor stellar. While it certainly boasts a few ostensibly far-reaching, intellectual ideas, they’ve all relied on vagaries and innuendo to promote themselves. Not to dismiss the title’s concepts entirely, but at the end of the day, it’s just your usual secret society power plays with a dose of sci-fi and philosophy thrown in.
None of that is enough to keep your interest vested in the long, dry periods between issues, especially when Hickman insists on emphasizing the same points over and over: da Vinci and Newton in a war of ideas; Leonid stalling between them; Howard Stark, Nathaniel Richards, and Night Machine hanging around; and Michelangelo taking it all in with a smirk—in the buff. This has been the status quo for nearly the last year, which is a major problem by any standard.
A comic that chooses to go without text is a very artsy, ambitious conceit, but that means the story has to have such substance that words aren’t necessary. In this case, it feels more like the substance is so formulaic and straightforward that words would only be redundant. After all, with a mad Celestial rampaging around the Immortal City, you essentially have a fancier, more cosmically driven Godzilla flick, and we all know how that goes.
For all the craziness that goes on, it only reveals that Celestials, shockingly enough, are a bugger to kill. Don’t expect to learn anything about what drives the Celestial forward or why it’s after Newton. Nonsense math started this, and nonsense math (courtesy of Michelangelo) ends it. As usual, it all has the gloss of high-concept sophistication, but no real meat to chew on, so the story doesn’t go much of anywhere.
In fact, by the end of the issue, our heroes are about to embark on a journey we all knew was coming: to go after Newton. And once again, you’ll have to wait another two months before you see that crazy-eyed genius get what’s coming to him. If Hickman can somehow pull off an awe-inspiring conclusion of staggering proportions, then perhaps all the patience you’ve invested into this series will be worth it, but as it stands, that doesn’t seem altogether very likely.
Well, at least the extensive breaks in time have apparently afforded Weaver the time to deliver some stunning artwork. With Oback’s electric colors, at least the series looks like a cinematic epic. You get some grand splashes in this issue, but none more so than of the Star Child teleporting itself after Newton, leaving behind a bubble of time-space that causes the surrounding buildings to collapse.
Conclusion: This comic has gotten a little too big for its own britches. It expects respect and attention for the far reach of its ideas, but delivers very scant story in return. Unless the next issue blows minds, this series will land rather unceremoniously in the Dropped List.
Grade: C
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – We all know that the start of a new adventure means new outfits, right?
Grade
Conclusion