
By: Tab Murphy (writer), Sam Liu & Lauren Montgomery (directors), Bryan Cranston, Eliza Dushku, Benjamin McKenzie (voice actors)
The Story: Uplifting a depraved city takes more than just putting on some tights, you know.
The Review: No matter how grim cartoons get, we still rarely think of them as truly edgy or dangerous, at least enough to satisfy the adult palette. Japanese animators have been doing this kind of dramatic work for years, basically, but of all the American producers, only DC has ventured into that territory with commercial success. With each yearly release of their animated films, they’ve shown a willingness to take bigger risks, yielding more fruitful results each time.
You can see the evolution in the animation. All-Star Superman showed subtle signs of moving toward an anime standard of production, but in this film, it’s unmistakable, beautiful, and fitting. By now, DC has grown quite formidable at depicting action, but here they show surprising aptitude for subtle body movements and changes in expression that gives a whole new level of craft to the “acting.” The animation itself shows emotion, even without the voice actors’ help.
But then, we’re working with a pretty excellent source to begin with. Anyone who’s flipped through Frank Miller’s original story arc knows what a groundbreaking piece of work it is. So much of its success derives from what Miller left brilliantly unspoken; as aggressive as it seems, most of its tension feels almost subconscious. This film is about as faithful an adaptation of all those qualities as it can get, and remains gripping nearly its entire length as a result.
If you want to capture the Miller spirit, you better just go for it, and Murphy, Montgomery, and Liu pull no punches. Fifteen minutes in, you’ve got violent cops, corruption almost visibly festering in all places, fist-fights with pimps and prostitutes, underage hookers stabbing men in the thigh, even (unless I misheard it) an F-bomb at one point. Heck, you even get to see a couple stark-naked men, bound up and lying (privates-side down) around.
As you might tell, the film wastes no time, employing tasteful and smart cuts to keep the suspense high and clipping along, but also to draw out and develop some powerful imagery. Check out the intercutting between Gordon taking shots at the firing range and him and his pregnant wife viewing the sonogram of their coming child. The cut from the image of the fetus’ head to the body outline Gordon just put a headshot through is especially thrilling.
While McKenzie does fine as Batman, taking on in his narration a Dexter-ish deadened tone (occasionally drifting into irritatingly stiff), Cranston’s Gordon makes this movie, his gravelly voice sanding over each line with a rough weariness. He really becomes the emotional center you most empathize with. His one-man struggle for justice against the corruptive pressure from all sides feels palpable at times.
Batman and Gordon’s growing awareness and relationship with each other form the spine of this film. While each views the other with suspicion at first, you can see them slowly gauging how they can each work to the other’s mutual advantage. Gordon’s devotion to the law binds his hands at times, but Batman can do what needs to be done so Gordon can accomplish his own vendetta against Gotham’s inbred nature of crime. It’s a very exciting synergy you get to see develop between them.
While Catwoman (played by the commendable Dushku) seems a bit out of place in this two-man drama, she serves a very useful contrast to both. If Gordon is the face of the law, and Batman is vengeance personified, then Selina is the rebel, lashing out against circumstances in her own way, motivated nearly as much by notoriety as her desire to be in control for once. No wonder having her acts attributed to Batman sends her in such a rage: “Now I’m his assistant?!”
On top of everything else, you get a fairly strong soundtrack, courtesy of Christopher Drake. The sharp strings that softly pierce the most dramatic scenes channel vibes from the great thrillers, and you can also hear influences from Watchmen and Sin City in the epic rock sound that plays over a few of the cityscape scenes and the end credits.
Conclusion: Quite possibly one of the most remarkable and sophisticated commercial animated works in this hemisphere. Considering Batman: The Animated Series started DC on this path, it’s only fitting that Batman would offer the material for one of their best efforts yet.
Grade: A
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – A call girl seems completely flummoxed by what Bruce asks of her: “Grape juice and small talk… Can I go now? You guys are weird.”
– Why are the corrupt always portrayed as overweight men?
Grade
Conclusion